Neverending, I honestly love your passion for the movies you love and the horror genre in general, and I love reading your posts, so please don't take this personally :)
But if I remember correctly, you said recently that you didn't consider Alien to be a horror movie (and I actually agree!), but I am sure you can find that on many "best of horror" lists as well.
Anyway my honest opinion is, if we vote/give negative votes/back/withdraw backings based on other people's opinions and not on our own, then we might as well just copy one of the other many many lists of "horror movies that the critics were paid to say that we must like, so we will add them even if we haven't seen them". The list wouldn't actually reflect if the movies on it are any good or not.
What will make this list interesting is seeing the opinions of "real people", and not movie critics who aren't brave enough to have their own individual opinions. Sure, some choices so far have made me think "whaaaat?!", but I am curious to see what a list created by actual horror fans will look like when it's completed.
|