interesting moral question

[bloodrayne]

I would never even contemplate such a thing...Ressurection or not, I would never hurt anyone that I love...Even for a minute...NOTHING would be worth it

[Rotting Eye]

Not even if the one you loved was planning on hurting you?

[Sam The Egg]

They'd be better off afterwards. I mean, I would want proof, and a 30 day trial first, cause I'm no idiot. But if it was completely on the up-and-up, logistically it'd be dumb NOT to.

[DarkwingMantis]

Well. Ive had this convo with my ex... if they kept comming back.... to hell with it. Yeah I brutally murder them for a lark!!!

[Rotting Eye]

Why would you even need the other two options? If you were God, you could make them happen anyway.

Where'd you find this faulty question? :p

[bloodrayne]

Originally posted by Rotting Eye
Not even if the one you loved was planning on hurting you?

Actually, I don't believe that was part of the original premise...However, if you are just asking personally...NO, I would not...No matter what

[Sam The Egg]

I got it off an anime board.

Once again, the person would be better off afterwards if you did it

[Rotting Eye]

Well, it wasn't part of the original question.

Although, you said you'd never hurt the one you loved, so I posed a question to see if I could find out if it were true.

But then again, I don't believe that anyone truly knows what they'd do in any high stress situation.

For example, if a killer came into your house, you can say you'd protect your children first over your own life, and your wives, but you don't know. You can't make a judgement like that until it really happens. The combination of stress, adrenaline, etc... You just don't know what you'd do until it actually happened.

[bloodrayne]

Originally posted by Rotting Eye
if a killer came into your house, you can say you'd protect your children first over your own life, and your wives, but you don't know. You can't make a judgement like that until it really happens. The combination of stress, adrenaline, etc... You just don't know what you'd do until it actually happened.

In a situation such as you have described, it may be difficult to think clearly...In such situations instinct usually prevails...It is a mother's natural instinct to protect her children first, even over her own life

[Rotting Eye]

Originally posted by bloodrayne
In a situation such as you have described, it may be difficult to think clearly...In such situations instinct usually prevails...It is a mother's natural instinct to protect her children first, even over her own life

That was only one example. Pick any example from an unlimited array where you're probably not thinking clearly.

Which is my point... Until you're in a limited, high stress environment like that, you don't know what you'd do.