Good topic - Was just recently thinking about this myself...
The Awesome- Stoker - Hands down brilliant
- You're Next - Thoroughly enjoyed this one but need to see it again; had a distracting audience experience
- The World's End - Loved it
The OK- The Conjuring - Didn't love this as much as everyone else seems to
- American Mary - I was hoping that it would push the envelop more than it did. Ending was a HUGE disappointment especially
- Evil Dead - Enjoyed this one; thought the gore was especially great
- Dark Skies - Not bad. I can see why people liked this one.
The Bad- Mama - Hugely disappointing, especially the awful terrible gag-worthy end
- The Purge - Too bad; really liked the concept. Could have said a lot of interesting things about socioeconomic divides.
- World War Z - Bleah.
- Warm Bodies - Rob Cordray was the best part of this movie. The rest I found pretty Meh.
Haven't Seen- Byzantium - Pretty psyched to see this actually
- Lords of Salem - I know it's getting terrible feedback but I am still unavoidably curious
- Insidious 2 - While I thought that the first movie was uneven and weak toward the end, there was enough that I did like about it (or at least I found interesting) that makes me want to see this
- Maniac - Not sure if it's my sub-genre, but I am very curious about this one
- Escape from Tomorrow - Really intrigued by this one