Quote:
Originally Posted by Sculpt
It's an interesting idea. One good thing about all of us picking 6 films is we get past the pet films everyone has demonstrated they have, and we get a wider consensus and find common appreciations of notable works.
|
Although I see your point, I think it becomes a problem if we have to back "just to back", if that makes any sense. Maybe that's just me, but I think you should back a movie because you think it deserves to be on the list, and not because "I'm missing 2, I guess I've got to pick something... "
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sculpt
For personal consideration/discussion: should any of us really decide to neg any films with the initial intent of try to 'make room' for another film we prefer? Rather, we seemed to have had been building a precedence, not only that negging would be extremely rare, but also that one wouldn't neg a film for being merely OK, but rather extremely bad in some way.
|
I totally agree with this. It shouldn't become a competition about who gets to have their favourite movies on the list. I wouldn't neg vote something unless I REALLY thought it was dreadful. But - NOT telling others what to do, this is just my personal opinion on neg voting.