[roshiq]

List submitted so far...
1. Bwind
2. Newb
3. Roshiq
4. Horror4ever
5. Novarku
6. Posher778
7. FreddyMyers
8. Fiend_skull
9. TheWickerFan
10. Rodric Usher
11. Weapon X
12. Zwoti
13. Straker
14. Fridaythe13thFan

(Only listed movies with more than 1 vote)

Movies with (highest) 11votes:
1. Let the Right One In
2. The Mist

Movies with 10 votes:
3. The Descent
4. Martyrs
5. The Orphanage
6. REC.

Movies with 9 votes:
1. Behind the Mask: Leslie Vernon
2. Cloverfield
3. The Devil's Rejects
4. Drag me to Hell
5. Fido
6. The Host
7. Hostel
8. Wolf Creek
9. Zombieland

Movies with 8 votes:
1. 28 weeks later
2. 1408
3. Inside
4. Paranormal Activity
5. Saw II
6. Trick 'r Treat

Movies with 7 Votes:
1. 30 Days of Night
2. Feast
3. Grindhouse (Planet Terror & Death Proof)
4. Halloween
5. Hatchet
6. The House of the Devil
7. Midnight Meat Train

Movies with 6 votes:
1. Eden Lake
2. Pan’s Labyrinth
3. The Hills have Eyes
4. Silent Hill

Movies with 5 votes:
1. Black Sheep
2. Cold Prey
3. Diary of the Dead
4. Frontier(s)
5. The Hills run Red
6. My name is Bruce
7. Resident Evil: Extinction
8. The Ruins
9. Slither
10. Teeth
11. Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning

Movies with 4 votes:
1. 2001 Maniacs
2. Day Watch
3. Dead Snow
4. The Exorcism of Emily Rose
5. The Girl next Door
6. Grace
7. Hostel: Part 2
8. Ils/Them
9. La Horde
10. Mr. Brooks
11. Pandorum
12. Pontypool
13. Quarantine
14. REC. 2
15. Reincarnation
16. Saw III
17. See No Evil
18. The Signal
19. The Skeleton Key
20. The Strangers
21. Triangle
22. Vacancy

Movies with 3 votes:
1. An American Haunting
2. Art of the Devil 2
3. Bug
4. Carriers
5. Cello
6. The Children
7. The Cottage
8. Doomsday
9. Final Destination 3
10. Friday the 13th
11. Halloween 2
12. Hannibal Rising
13. Home Movie
14. The Human Centipede (First Sequence)
15. Laid to Rest
16. Land of the Dead
17. One Missed Call 2
18. Orphan
19. Outpost
20. P2
21. Philosophy of a Knife
22. Re Cycle
23. Severance
24. Snakes on a Plane
25. Underworld: Evolution
26. White Noise

Movies with 2 votes:
1. Alone
2. Antichrist
3. Arang
4. AVP: Requiem
5. Borderland
6. Broken
7. The Burrowers
8. Catacombs
9. Cinderella
10. Cold Prey 2
11. The Collector
12. Cry_Wolf
13. Dead Silence
14. Dead Space: Downfall
15. Dread
16. Evil Aliens
17. The Eye [US Reamke]
18. Fear(s) of the Dark (Animation)
19. The 4th Kind
20. Grudge 2
21. Hard Candy
22. Hush
23. Isolation
24. I sell the Dead
25. Joshua
26. The Last House on the Left
27. The Machine Girl
28. Mirrors
29. The Mother of Tears
30. Mulberry Street
31. Mum & Dad
32. My Bloody Valentine 3D
33. Naboer
34. Noroi
35. Perfume: The Story of a Murderer
36. The Rage
37. The Red Shoes
38. Rest Stop
39. Repo! The Generic Opera
40. Right at your Door
41. Rovdyr aka Manhunt
42. Saw 4
43. SAW 5
44. Sheitan
45. Shrooms
46. Shutter
47. Sick Nurses
48. Silk
49. SL8N8
50. Splinter
51. Spiral
52. Strange Circus
53. Sweeny Todd
54. Timber Falls
55. Tokyo Gore Police
56. The Uninvited
57. Voices aka Someone behind you
58. Wilderness
59. The Woods
60. The Wizard of Gore
61. Zodiac
62. The Zombie Diaries
63. Zombies of Mass Destruction
64. Zombie Strippers

Note: We can't take the following films into consideration for this project as they got wide scale or international release after 2009:

Daybreakers
The Final Destination
Legion
A Nightmare on Elm Street
Resident Evil: Afterlife
Splice
Survival of the Dead
The Wolfman