Quote:
Originally Posted by The STE
"hee hee... Oh, the thin splitting hairs of a meticulously semantic argument. "
If you make a statement that is completely and utterly wrong, don't blame me for explaining why you're an idiot.
"Both comparative insults could be inferred to be ironic attempts at sardonic ignorance, which was my point. But really, miscommunication is truly a part of the joy of the anonymity and ambiguous nature of posting on a forum... "
One was "feigning" ignorance in response to a completely blatant statement. The other was taking advantage of the vagueness of a statement. Do I need to make a chart or something? I could have the Muppet Babies come in and explain it to you if you think you could understand them better.
|
hahahaha... I think you just made my morning. And I haven't even had coffee yet.
You
are making a semantic argument and
both "insults" were feigning ignorance by blatantly ignoring the intent of the initial statement, though using different means ("insults" being in quotation marks as neither of them were particularly effective, yours or Disease's).
But I don't think that it even matters. This thread has gotten WAY off topic.
I actually think that you made an interesting analysis here:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The STE
Freddy vs. Jason never really happened (within the cannon of the story. Obviously it never REALLY happened). The whole thing was Jason in hell. He was killing because of his mother, not because he got a kick out of it. If not for her and the events of the first F13 movie, he wouldn't be killing anybody. So he goes to hell and ends up having to kill for someone else and is basically powerless to fight against it.
Either that or it did happen, and Jason was given a more tangible, waking hell. Remember, Freddy apparently became some kinda demon (or was always a demon if FvsJ is going by the New Nightmare cannon) so it's not out of the question that he'd have some power in hell.
|
However, just because someone on this forum disagrees with your film analysis, doesn't mean that you should be an asshole, i.e.:
Quote:
Originally Posted by The STE
So, what, we just disregard what is arguably the central event in the history of the character? Who cares what would've happened if she didn't die the way she did? That's the way it was written. It's the motivation given for the character's actions, regardless of what Dumb Fuck Aussie thinks about it.
|
If the purpose of your joining this thread is to argue that Freddy Vs. Jason only happens on the plane of Jason's Hell, then do it. That's interesting and well thought-out. Let's go back there. And stop being a douche about it.
...
If Freddy Vs. Jason is Jason's Hell... Does that mean that killing for him is eternal suffering? And his mom is a sort of surrogate Devil that he serves? Or is she just a manifestation of the Devil (if there is a Devil that presides over Hell)?