Round 1: Match 31
Paradise Lost: The Child Murders at Robin Hood Hills
Zombies, ghosts, serial killers, vampires, aliens, bah! THIS is the really scary shit. Documentary about the West Memphis Three, accused and convicted of the murder of three first grade boys, mostly on the basis that they wore a lot of black and listened to heavy metal and weren't strict christians. Show of hands, how many people here fit that description? Infuriating that they were convicted, and frightening in that there are people like this right now. This shit could happen to any one of us. What are the odds of a zombie outbreak?
VS
High Fidelity
John Cusack vehicle, with one of his stronger performances next to Say Anything, and with a great and funny supporting cast, highlighted by Jack Black. Written very well, making Cusack's character an ass, but still likeable.
I'll cast a vote for Paradise Lost right now.