Screw it, Ill post the answer.
It's The Reaper, a really low budget flick with Chris Sarandon. I got it really cheap in a bargain bin...it's dumb and predictable, plus has a few too many plot twists at the end, but Id say worth seeing once.
Somebody else can do the next one.
IMDb page:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0203830/