since they're probably gonna want to go with a name, I'd say Jason Lee. Sans beard he looks about right, he's a hell of an actor, not so sure about being evil, but I wouldn't doubt he could pull it off. If they go with a name, I hope they pick him (if one considers him a 'name')
or (another possibly unpopular pick) what about Ryan Gosling?
He looks about right, and was great in The Believer