And the Winner will be...
 

All this talk about a new movie from New Line involving Freddy vs Michael vs Jason gave me this idea...if all of em were to square off in a huge battle...

who do you think will win in a battle of the screen monsters?

good question

freddy shouldnt even be apart of it, mike and jason.............jason of course,
although im a major halloween and m. myers fan.

well we no now jason can kinda take freddy so realy its can jason take micheal and isay no micheal will win. go michael myers

The Alien.

I'd love to see all of the other icons cocooned with little chest-bursters erupting from their chests. Can't you just see it?

Jason's chest cracking open as a baby alien explodes out... Drac sinking his teeth into a face-hugger only to have its acid blood burn his face off.

Poll is up. Choose, ye mortals.;)

That would be some battle alrite. Though Ash by himself...he would have his hands full...unless he had someone by his side? The Predator maybe?

so is that gonna happen, or was the ash vs. jason vs. freddy still a rumor?

Cant say yet. New Line has commissioned scripts on both, a prequel to NOES and a Freddy vs Jason vs Michael script...so lets wait and see. Till then, who do you think will win a battle of the 10 heavyweights of the monsters?

Raimi doesn't want to release the rights. It won't happen.

But MY NAME IS BRUCE is coming soon, and it sounds awesome.

Remember, most of em are pretty immortal. Jason, Michael, Freddy, Dracula, Frankie, Pinhead...but some can be a handful and really vicious, the Werewolf, the Alien etc.

So choose carefully, fellow HDCers.:cool:

Jason. He's got the most kills in movie history to his name, plus he kicked Freddy's butt nicely in FvJ, plus he can take on any one of the rest by himself.

hmm its just a fantasy poll, but what if Jason squares off against Dracula? One hack to the head clean off maybe? or a huge stab of the machete through the heart? And if Drac sinks his teeth into Jason's neck, do we have a vampire Jason on our hands? :eek:

I feel excited about some of the battles this poll conjures up in the imagination.

Nice reply. I would like to urge more fellow members to vote in this poll, citing your reason why you picked that movie monster. Lets see if we can have a clear winner emerging.

Do the chest bursters need a living being to gestate in? Wouldn't Jason's body just be a corpse in their eyes?

As far as Drac, there wouldn't really be anything but coagulated blood in Jason would there?

Obviously I think Jason would win.

My breakdown of the fight: Pinhead. Although it's unfair to include him because he embodies an ideology and is part of some sort of cosmic balance.Thus, to ask who would win in a fight against Pinhead is like asking who would win in a fight against the quotation mark or the concept of salad. Pinhead's only weakness is his love of pleabargaining. I guess if Freddy got him on some kind of gameshow Freddy would win, because Pinhead is usually willing to back down in exchange for more souls or maybe a dinette set, or the location of some sinner. He gives in way too easily for somebody who's such a ranging ideologue. Between the others who could actually fight fair against each other, the winner would be Jason, because the Alien bursting from his chest would only be a source of momentary confusion and annoyance for Jason. The American Werewolf has cool effects, but little in the way of combat prowess. The mummy would just find a bog to sink into and be distracted by yet another reincarnation of his lost love.

this has been done a couple times before, and the only possible answer would be Jason or Michael Myers, simply because they cant be killed.

Alien. Nature always defeats man, and Jason IS man. Plus, alien is way more elusive than jason, and would have him ripped to pieces in a second.

Dracula would ultimately come out on top,Firstly he has the power to change himself into a mist,which is pretty handy for defensive purposes (How can you Stab,slash,saw or bite mist? )
Secondly Dracula can raise the dead thus creating an army of undead grunts to take out those opponents who are not immortal.
Thirdly Dracula has the power of Mind control which would enable him to make what remains of his foes do whatever the hell he pleases.
Yep,Dracula for me..........he would,however,be fucked at sun up!

My vote went to alien!

Isn't the correct answer obviously Pinhead? He see,s far and away the most powerful. I'd think he'd dominate.

My bets are on Michael. And this is why:

Jason: He's big and immortal, although he is in turn, a little on the dumb side.

Freddy: As long as you don't go to sleep, you'll be fine.

Leatherface: He's tough, but he's still a mortal.

Dracula: He can be killed at dawn or by a wooden stake.

Frankenstein: He's a human doctor! What's he going to do against these other guys?

Frankenstein's Monster: He isn't immortal...

The Mummy: He's waaaay too slow to be taken seriously.

American Werewolf: Last time I checked, werewolves can be killd by a silver object of sorts.

The Alien: This one can also be killed....Predator showed us that.

Pinhead: He's pretty tough, but he has died and as long as you can get him back in the box, you're fine.

Michael on the other hand, he has been shot, stabbed and pretty much damaged in every way possible, but he never goes away.

:)

Dont think Freddy has much of a chance here.
If he drags the Alien into one of his nightmares, it wont be of much difference because the Alien doesnt care about its sorroundings, as long as there's something living upon which it can pounce.
Freddy can create a daylight scene for Dracula, but because its a dream, Dracula wont be affected much either.
Some of these guys are pretty fearless, and Freddy will have a hard time getting into their heads and finding out what their worst fears are.

Some nice points covered ^ there. (though by Frankenstein, I did mean the monster, not the doctor)

Excellent points by DP & Doc. Although Pinhead can be killed and sent back to the netherworld too, and Drac also has his weaknesses. What about the Werewolf? Sure he can be killed by a silver bullet but do the other 9 know that? Jason or Michael dont go around carrying silver with them. The Alien doesnt stop to think about its killing. Its as fast as the Alien and can rip you to shreds in a second. But of course, it is dependent on the full moon...or is it?

hmm...

Dracula wouldn't have much real blood to drink in this fight. I would love to see a movie where Drac sneaks up on Jason and sinks his teeth into Jasons neck only to have Jason cock his head in confusion before swinging around and taking Drac's head off heh.

My choice obviously would be Jason. Some might argue that he has killed only humans before, but he did a great job of banging Freddy up nicely in Freddy vs Jason. As far as Michael goes, it will be interesting to see how he fares against Jason. Dracula might be a handful but decapitation does stop him in his tracks, and some of these killers are experts at lopping the head off. Frankenstein is a set of bandages and stitches, so can be taken to pieces in no time. Same goes for the Mummy too. Pinhead would be the only adversary who could give the others a tough time.

After pt.6, Jason didnt have much blood left in him. What about Michael though? Would he turn into a vampire if bitten by Dracula?

It would be interesting to think about the scene between the Alien and Dracula too. What do they do when against each other? Does Drac stand a chance against Alien's acid and teeth? or will the Alien turn if bitten?

The Mummy seems to be getting a bad "wrap" here. Depending on which version/mythology he DOES have a lot of supernatural powers. I think he'd be more than a handful, I wonder how an Alien would fight in a sandstorm because environment would play a HUGE part in this one. I think the werewolf against an Alien would be a hell of a fight to see too...

As far as the Aliens and Dracula, unless it was holy water those creatures were bleeding it wouldn't matter. Acid can't kill the count right? Drac would also have a distinct advantage when it came to picking his spot add that to his super strenght and intelligence and he'd have a fighting chance. Would he try to bite the undead or simply try and kill them? Dracula would probably be the smartest one in the fight and he could fly around waiting for his spot. Michael turning is a good thought but who knows if draining Michael of his blood would turn or kill him, it may just feed The Shape and make him stronger.

Hell yes. One of those lycans of Underworld would be quite a match for the Alien.

Of course the Mummy doesnt stand a chance without its powers. But given its all powerful, on its day, the Mummy can win against any of the 9 listed, or all of em. I think the Mummy is powerful enough to take on anyone.

Michael has been disposed off many times and has managed to return everytime. So I am thinking Drac's bite may not have the desired effect it should.

What if a face-hugger attaches itself to Drac and knocks him out senseless while planting an Alien inside him? Would we have an Alien with vampire powers bursting his chest and coming out?

or if the warewolf scratches an alien, the transormation would be death to all.

I like to keep things simple, so I could see the Alien ripping them all to shreds...It's big, powerful, fast and vicious

Even if the others aren't technically 'dead'...They would still have lost once they have been dismembered and disabled


Then Ash comes along and blows the Alien's head off with his shotgun...If he can take out demons, he can take out an Alien

The Alien could be outnumbered if 2-3 of those listed get together against it. And it can be killed too. If a wussy Predator can do it, I m sure the Werewolf could finish it off in seconds. The only factor keeping it interesting would be its acid for blood.

The Werewolf and the Alien do have speed as their assets, but one cant ignore someone like Pinhead who can stop them dead in their tracks.

It will be mighty interesting to see Pinhead square off against the Alien. Would it be hooked in chains and ripped to pieces, or will the acid dissolve the chains and the creature has Pinhead for lunch?

The Alien is badass. You cant keep it quiet if anything living is prowling near it, unless the Queen calls it back of course (like in Aliens and AvP).
Given the day, the Werewolf is no match for it. It would be a bunch of bloody fur and meat in no time at all. The Alien can be really vicious and keep coming at you, while the Werewolf spends a lot of time snarling at its enemy.
That, my friend, will always be an advantage for the Alien.

It would just... be Alien. There's no doubt about it. the alien has no real weaknesses, pain doesn't hinder it from being vicious in the least, and neither do it's surroundings. It has acid blood, so any machete slash or stab would get it on the attacker in some way and sizzle a part of them off, and it's teeth are unbreakable! It has an evil tongue too, that can pierce a skull with ease, and a slash/stab tail. It has more stealth than an invisible ant, and it's prey is always dead on the ground in about a second. PLUS, all of it's weapons and tactics are 100% natural! It doesn't even use knives or anything like the rest.

Predator....


We're talking ONE Alien here right? Not a whole nest... otherwise we'd have to give Dracula the win because he could just keep making soldiers until the war is won for him. Acid doesn't bother vampires much, only holy water. Besides, as we've seen before, the Alien could keep killing Jason over and over again and it wouldn't matter because he would keep coming back.

But alien could stake him with his tail.

Alien could tear jason to pieces, him coming back to life holds no significance in one fight.

His tail isn't made of wood.

I don't think it matters

Depends on the lore you're going by... I agree with the legend of the "must be wooden" stake. In some cases, any stake will do; in others, it must be wood; and to get the greatest possible damage done, the stake must be made of hawthorn, ash, juniper or hawthorn.