This one got closer as I thought about it. For real scares, The Thing holds its own with any horror film, and The Fly was very well done for its day. But in the end, you just can't beat Alien (Aliens). Dog Soldiers was great, but you could have put The Descent and still won it. Hell, you could have teamed it with The Cave.

Although, I was convinced Ripley would win. :o

Alien and Werewolf take a 2-1 lead.

We need more votes people!

Alien and Werewolf

alien and werewolf....

The Thing, and the fly.

alien and werewolf

the thing and the fly

Alien & werewolf

Thing and Brundle Fly

The Thing and the Fly