While it's far from a great movie, I found The Reaper to be a fairly enjoyable murder-mystery. Chris Sarandon pulled off an above average performance, despite being the only person involved who could act their way out of a wet paper bag. It had a few too many twists, and the ending was beyond predictable...but it was still pretty enjoyable, mostly due to Sarandon's character, obviously inspired by something from King.

The Reaper

1-0, Reaper takes a surprising lead!

Im voting for the fish

The Reaper

2-1, Reaper (WOW!!!)

Yeah...Me too...Because I haven't seen The Reaper...I'm not sure if that even makes me ELIGIBLE to vote...

Hell yeah it does! You can still vote even if you haven't seen either movie before. Doesn't matter to me. You could go by which you think would be better/looks better/heard it was better/etc.

2-2, Tie

Since this is a slow match-up, I'm going to throw my vote in for Piranha.

3-2, Piranha now takes the lead!

Piranha

Piranha!!!