My most watched horrors are plenty but just off the top of my head :

Jaws. Hmmm about 30 times i think but not really sure.

Phantasm
Dawn of the Dead (original of course)
My Bloody Valentine (original)

The usual staple of the classic Universal monsters,Franky,Drac,Wolfie etc

Oh hell yeah, how could I forget Jaws?! I have seen that dozens and dozens of times. In fact, just seeing your post makes me want to give it one last look before the summers gone. To the movie shelf I go!!

I had a unhealthy House of 1000 Corpses obsession for a long time. I wore out two discs. Now I only watch it a few times a year. But yeah, it was bad.

And of course Repo! I watched it about a thousand times that first month it released and I still listen to the soundtrack in the car all the time.

AHHHH and the Toxic Avenger. Probably a million times.

Jaws

watch it every summer

In what must be the most mathematically impossible occurrence, I at one time or another, went on a binge watch of each of these titles. On occasion I enjoy a movie so much that it doesn't leave my player for days, or even weeks. That was the case with House, Repo and Toxie for me.

Same wave length brother. Great minds and whatnot. My dad introduced me to Toxie when I was 5. All the other kids had normal batman and superman action figures, I had a toxic avenger action figure. It came with the mop and everything.

Sounds like you had a proper horror kid upbringing, man! Kudos to your dad for his wicked good taste, and his wise choice of passing Toxie down the family bloodline.

If it makes it any easier to understand this is my pops at 56. Not the best picture, its from a promo shot of his band.