I think it would make for a much better show if it catered to an older audience. The horror elements feel watered down and censored. It's not nearly violent enough for my tastes. But I like the idea behind it.

Probably because the ratings won't allow it....stupid tv:p

If you have Sky you can sometimes see it on Zone Horror.

I have season 1 on DVD.

I've never actually watched it. But I'm sure I'd prefer Reaper.

But since you suggested it I'll give it a look.

I enjoy Supernatural as well, its a fun show. When it first started, I wasn't sure, but really, it has just just gotten better and better as it goes along for the most part, in my opinion. And the soundtrack is indeed awesome. So now I watch every week. :)