sooo let me get this straight. your saying we need to go back to basics ala steaks kill vamps, silver bullets kill lycanthropes. well correct me if im wrong but in American Werewolf in London, the bullets that killed peter werent silver, nor the one that brought down jacks attacker. Point im trying to make is this, London broke the rules and was still (IMO) the greatest werewolf movie ever made. I think it has little to do with rules and more to do with overall movie making steze. Look at gingersnaps- broke the rules- still a great flick.

review
 

I watched the movie myself last night and I agree it could have been better. I wish the fighting between werewolves and vampires were longer. They could have choreographed wonderful fight scenes without all that Matrix mumbo jumbo (i.e. the vampire with silver whips v. that werewolf).

Another thing I noticed was that the Vampires had a reflection.... :confused:

ha pearl harbor was awesome as far as gore goes most war movies are! although it was a little sad to watch hartnett die..........ponders..........no, i enjoyed it!

j-lo????? only if she gets ripped to shreads buy a rabbid 4 yr old named sven! and i do agree w/ you on some terms w/ the whole genetic mutation thing but i do like horror and i dont do romantic comedys *they give me gas* *not really*

It's not just AWL that broke the rules. Lots of literature and films have broken the rules, because many of the rules sucked. However, there are plenty of traditionalists out there that like their vamp steak (get it...sarcasm abounds) and their werwolves killed with silver.

As for this movie (Underground) isn't it just Blade witha chick and some werwolves?? I don't know, honestly. I won't go see anything my ex would like.

Traditionalists or not, that's why I created my own set of rules in my novel writing (short story writing doesn't count). I wanted something original and not just borrowed from a wornout set of rules. I got tired of the same old same old and I'm sure some of you have also.

In my novel writing, vampires can be seen in a mirror. Why? Because they're flesh, they have mass. Just because they're dead doesn't mean that they are invisible. LOL :)

wow, a lot of negative responses for underworld. its not out yet where i am (australia) i was actually looking forward to seeing it.....i still will, but ill lower my expectations a wee bit heh

You better lower them a bit more LOL

LOL

its not just the negativity
 

im rather glad i brought this whole subject, because it seems to me the people have alot of contaversy on the whole matter of what kills what. dont lower your expectations too much otherwise you wont have any fun pointing out all of the mistakes, well not mistakes really just the different point of view this director had. and he's not a bad director, it's just some people prefer to stick to the basics. and now that i really think about it he took a risk in the whole horror world, not that people haven't already, but he changed the rules to fit to what he thought was good and for any director thats brilliant! :D