well i know i sure as hell didnt order that rental store DVD case.

The listing should have said something like "EX-RENTAL IN STORE CASE."

The same thing happened to me...I bought a DVD of "Below" (cheap, though) and it came in a Blockbuster case, and it's such a good movie that it irritated me, so I found an empty keep case, pulled the artwork out, and switched it into the empty case. It's horrible to have a cool video in a lame box, for some reason.