sorry guys.. i gave this one about a 2... it really left a pretty bad taste in my mouth ... i'm getting pretty sick of seeing bad CG

i think this movie was really a "fan movie"... not to say that people who aren't fans of the comic wouldn't enjoy the movie, just that those that are would adore it or think it's "a work of art" ( and yes, people have said this ).

5/10... it was alright.

Mediocre. I'd say maybe a 6 out of 10.

I definitely didn't view it as a horror movie (and I don't think that was the film's intent).

But mediocre nonetheless.

I really wanted to smack that fish-guy up! Damn he was annoying...lol!

the fish guy was nothing but junk.. queer

as a movie i give it a 4, i got bored a few times during watching it, it could've been made great...but wasn't, it was watchable but nothing special, i watched Serial Killing 101 before i watched Hellboy and found that movie a lot better, gonna watch Open Water today, anyone seen that yet?

I would have to give the movie a 3. I didn't think it was all that good. BUT, I've never read the comic book before...so, If I had I may have actually liked it.

PSHH!!! NILES FROM FRAISER OWNS YOUR ASS!!!

No seriously, a 5....better than most in the genre....compare it to underworld or van hellsing....

i only gave it a 4 becasue i thought that it was greatly overrated and it just wasn't what i was expecting out of the movie
________
extreme q

Theatrical - 9/10
Directors Cut - 10/10