green day isn't punk... nothing is any more


aahhh. just fuck it, you're all idiots :o

nothings punk anymore? what about good charlotte:rolleyes:

yeah punks dead.

Fugazi - 23 beats off

they say they are.

NOFX - Fun Things To Fuck

i love punk ...

meaning The Sex Pistols ...

I like other bands that were inspired by punk ...

but its true ... there isn't punk anymore - i stand behind that 100%

calling what passes for punk today as 'punk' is like calling what passes for RnB today as 'RnB'

two distinct periods of music that stood for a lot more than just a look and a sound - that are long past.... unfortunately.


green day is about as 'punk' as The Monkees.


actually - less so.

Black Flag - Beat my head against the wall

Dead Kennedys have always been my favorite punk band, never liked the Sex Pistols that much.

I agree greenday isnt punk.
nor is all this blink 182 sum41 offspring bullshit.

but there is something I must disagree on.
punk is not dead. It's just sleeping:cool:

*sigh*.....We're arguing about what "punk" is?

We'll never get anywhere with this.
Why not just enjoy what you like listening to without having to label everything?
No one wrote a book on punk back in '76. The Ramones sang songs about movies. MOVIES!!! And everyone will agree that they were punk but there was no rebellion or political angle. They were just doing what they liked.

But I've probably just opened a new can of worms, haven't I?

by the way...I like the Monkees too.