|
Argh. The 3 best adaptations by far. We did a good job with the voting here.
Cinematically I would say this is a tie. Storywise Dark Knight get eliminated. I hate to come to this, but my vote goes to The Watchmen because I like the comic for that one a little more than I do for Sin City. |
The Dark Knight, no question.
|
Sin City...
|
the dark knight
|
Watchmen - 2
Sin City - 2 The Dark Knight - 2 All tied up. Keep em coming... |
The Dark Knight.
|
Sin City....
|
Sin City.............
|
Only because I really feel like it should win, do I pop in to vote for Sin City.
Now if it still doesn't, whatever. Since the place is still drowning in retards, I'm swimming out again. All the best. |
Quote:
|
The Dark Knight.
|
Sin City.........
|
The Dark Knight
|
Sin City - 6
The Dark Knight - 5 Watchmen - 2 Keep em coming... |
Sin City........
|
The Dark Knight
|
Sin City..........................
|
Sin City - 8
The Dark Knight - 7 Watchmen - 2 Keep em coming... |
Sin City..........
|
Watchmen .
|
Time to wrap this up and send it home in a little bow-tied ribbon...
Ladies and gentlemen... By beating two very strong and favored opponents, The Dark Knight and Watchmen, by a vote margin of 9-7-3, The winner...and the KING OF ALL COMIC-TO-MOVIE ADAPTATIONS EVER MADE... SIN CITY http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/...YL._SS500_.jpg http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/...NL._SS500_.jpg http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/...yL._SS500_.jpg http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/...JL._SS500_.jpg Thanks to each and every voter who was pretty charged up and excited while casting their votes in this tourney. It was pretty fun bringing it to all of you. While the result might be surprising to some, but to the majority I am sure it was a pretty correct outcome. Can there be a challenger to Sin City for this crown? Only time can tell. Thanks for another run to success, folks! You all rock! Ciao! ******************************TOURNAMENT CLOSED****************************** |
If only The Sandman had ever been adapted for the screen...sigh, I can only dream:cool:
|
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:01 PM. |