time traveller or not?

[wufongtan.]

Is the person in this film clip a time traveller, a old lady with a old fashion hearing aid. Or just cgi?
http://news.ninemsn.com.au/entertainment/8113964/time-traveller-makes-appearance-in-chaplin-film

If it's cgi. Then it's very very well done.

[Sistinas666]

Link won't work for me.:mad:

[neverending]

Saw this on Facebook. It's a hearing aid.

[bwind22]

Link won't work for me.:mad:



....ditto.

[The Ugly Duchess]

....ditto.

Same here.

[ChronoGrl]

Link didn't work for me either.

[phantomstranger]

Link didn't work for me either, but I saw the clip on the news. Gotta be some kind of hearing aid, but.....you never know

[_____V_____]

Fixed the link -

http://news.ninemsn.com.au/entertainment/8113964/time-traveller-makes-appearance-in-chaplin-film

It is a hearing aid.

EDIT - This is pretty much the solution right here - http://www.ghosttheory.com/2010/10/27/time-traveler-on-charlie-chaplins-movie-sigh

[wufongtan.]

Fixed the link -

http://news.ninemsn.com.au/entertainment/8113964/time-traveller-makes-appearance-in-chaplin-film

It is a hearing aid.

EDIT - This is pretty much the solution right here - http://www.ghosttheory.com/2010/10/27/time-traveler-on-charlie-chaplins-movie-sigh

I highly doubt it to be a actual time traveller. But it isn't a hearing aid. You can clearly see that.
1. it's just too small. And there is no large opening on the other end of the device she was holding.
2. It isn't connected to the white thing around her neck.
3. If it was. Why was she holding it up to ear, when no one was talking to her? Those things were virtually useless. And you practically had to yell into the open end for them to hear. So She would hardly be holding it up to her ear, to help her hear the noise of everyday life.
4.I think it's pretty clear. That her body language indicates she was talking to someone.

Sorry for the bad link. This one should work
http://news.ninemsn.com.au/entertainment/8113964/time-traveller-makes-appearance-in-chaplin-film

[neverending]

It's not an ear trumpet. It's a HEARING AID.

http://hearing.siemens.com/sg/10-about-us/01-our-history/milestones.jsp?year=1924

Why would someone be holding it up to their ear? SO THEY COULD HEAR THE AMPLIFIED SOUND.

However, the gullible and feeble-minded will always find ridiculous things to argue about, so proceed.

Also- do you have the slightest idea how a cell phone works? It sends a signal to a satellite dish, which then transmits the signal to a satellite orbiting the Earth. Did this time traveler bring her own dish and satellite with her to make the cell phone work?

[wufongtan.]

It's not an ear trumpet. It's a HEARING AID.

http://hearing.siemens.com/sg/10-about-us/01-our-history/milestones.jsp?year=1924

Why would someone be holding it up to their ear? SO THEY COULD HEAR THE AMPLIFIED SOUND.
Nope. Different shape than the one on your website all together.


However, the gullible and feeble-minded will always find ridiculous things to argue about, so proceed.

So it's gullible and feeble minded to ask questions?
I have not stated a postion one way or another. I have just questioned the answers to some of the questions is all. Myself. I'm certain, there is a logical answer. But until then. All questions must be asked. Instead of accepting the first, comfortable "answer" out of fear.

Also- do you have the slightest idea how a cell phone works? It sends a signal to a satellite dish, which then transmits the signal to a satellite orbiting the Earth. Did this time traveler bring her own dish and satellite with her to make the cell phone work?

I have some idea. But maybe it isn't a mobile phone? Maybe it's a communicator of some sort. Much akin to the old fashioned walkie talkies. Maybe she was talking to someone a few miles down the road.? Hmm?

[neverending]

And maybe it's all a bunch of bullshit.

The most telling detail in all of this is that the website the alleged filmmaker in the clip posts at the end doesn't even exist.

[wufongtan.]

And maybe it's all a bunch of bullshit.



If i was abetting man. I would bet my car, house and all my belongings that it is indeed bullshit. But..still. What i would like to see. Is the original film.

[Sistinas666]

Two Men and A Baby was a lot cooler before the ghost kid myth was debunked.

[endo]

Two Men and A Baby was a lot cooler before the ghost kid myth was debunked.

Agreed. I sat through that movie twice for that. Not a good viewing day.

[bwind22]

This just confirms that the Matrix is real and she's calling to get out.

[newb]

http://hearing.siemens.com/sg/10-about-us/01-our-history/milestones.jsp?year=1924

[neverending]

I already posted that link in post #10.

[newb]

I already posted that link in post #10.

my bad


..........................