And the battle is on...

[Vodstok]

This year, for the Emmy's, the following award is up for grabs:
Emmy Award for Outstanding Animated Program (For Programming One Hour Or More)

By the Blue Harvest episode of Family Guy (Star wars spoof) and South Park's Imagionationland trilogy.

Now,i used to be a pretty big Family Guy fan, I had all of the original episodes on my computer when it was first canceled, and still watched it pretty regularly when it was brought back.

However, South Park has always been ahead. it is way smarter and has much bigger balls. Needless to say, My vote goes to imagionationland.

if you havent seen them, go watch them before you vote. Dont be an uninformed voter (that goes for real voting too):
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2302524595200383460&q=blue+harvest&ei=bvmJSJXhF52mrALRh6WGCQ&hl=en

Imagionationland trilogy: (1 through 3)
http://www.southparkstudios.com/episodes/118663/
http://www.southparkstudios.com/episodes/124885/
http://www.southparkstudios.com/episodes/127561/


So watch them if you havent seen them and cast a vote.

[illdojo]

I also like both, but I vote South Park's Imagionationland Trilogy. Like you said Vod, they just have more balls.

[massacre man]

I hate Family Guy and Star Wars, so I guess it's pointless giving the Blue Harvest a watch.

But Imagination Land was great, so Imagination Land.

[Freak]

I love Family guy and South Park but I have to give it to SouthPark.Imagination Land was Awesome.

[GorePhobia]

I used to like South Park when it first came out but it's old now and doesn't really make me laugh. I like Family Guy in small doses anymore but I must admit that Blue Harvest was pretty funny.

[ChronoGrl]

Vod,

What happened to your little swordguy avatar? That's how I used to identify you.

Pls make him come back.

THX,
Chrono :p



And to actually post on topic, I haven't seen South Park's Imaginationland... And I thought Family Guys' Star Wars was totally overrated.

[ferretchucker]

I love them both completely and they were both brilliant, but all in all, Imagination land had me laughing harder so I give it my vote.

[The Mothman]

South park is the greatest show on television. Not only is it incredibly offensive and outrageous and funny, each episode is intelligent and expresses a great outlook on real issues. The Emmy is long due.

[Vodstok]

South Park is brilliant. It is the only thing i have seen that has come close to actually offending me (the steve irwin scene in Hell on Earth 2006, and the repeated references to his death in Stanley's cup), not to mention the fact that it is filled with subtext, which is rare in movies, let alone a tv show.


I love that EVERYONE is fair game.

[The Mothman]

Vod,

What happened to your little swordguy avatar? That's how I used to identify you.

Pls make him come back.

.

butters is way more badass.

[ferretchucker]

The thing I love about south park is the way the characters have progressed. Mr. Garrisson finding himself, Cartman going from selfish brat to cunning mastermind selfish brat. there are more, I just ca't think of any at the moment.

[Psycom5k]

Well incase anybody wants to watch the Imaginationland episodes, comedy central is playing them all tomorrow. Probably because of the nomination.

Oh and I voted for South Park, I thought that Blue Harvest was good, but Imaginationland was better.

[Vodstok]

Well incase anybody wants to watch the Imaginationland episodes, comedy central is playing them all tomorrow. Probably because of the nomination.

Oh and I voted for South Park, I thought that Blue Harvest was good, but Imaginationland was better.
my first post has links to imagionationland and blue harvest in case anyone wants to watch them :)

[Psycom5k]

my first post has links to imagionationland and blue harvest in case anyone wants to watch them :)

Yeah, but given the chance I'd rather watch something on a tv rather than a computer screen.

[Noah]

I fucking hate Family Guy, it's gaddamned garbage. South Park.

[Psycom5k]

I fucking hate Family Guy, it's gaddamned garbage. South Park.

Good for you, too bad you have no taste.

[massacre man]

Good for you, too bad you have no taste.

No, Family Guy is "gaddamned garbage".

[Freak]

No, Family Guy is "gaddamned garbage".

Family Guy is freaking amazing.It's funny and it's did something no other show has ever done.I mean a show has to be great for the dvd's to sell so well that they decide to bring the show back from the dead.Now that really says something.

But I do enjoy South Park more and Family Guy is a very close second.

[massacre man]

Family Guy is freaking amazing.It's funny and it's did something no other show has ever done.I mean a show has to be great for the dvd's to sell so well that they decide to bring the show back from the dead.Now that really says something.

So sales are quality?

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/2/24/Vanilla_Ice-To_the_Extreme_%28album_cover%29.JPG
Sold 7 million copies...

[Freak]

So sales are quality?

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/2/24/Vanilla_Ice-To_the_Extreme_%28album_cover%29.JPG
Sold 7 million copies...

In Family Guy's case,yes.And the only reason people bought that album was for Ice Ice Baby.plus that album didnt bring back his career either.

Might I ask why you hate Family Guy so much?

[massacre man]

Might I ask why you hate Family Guy so much?

1. How inconsistent the characters are. Where the fuck did the "Everybody hates Meg" come from? Since when is Stewie gay?
2. Musical numbers. I get it, Seth is a good singer. An occasional one is fine, but fuck.
3. Exact recreations just replacing characters. Like the Dazed and Confused gag with Brian.
4. How badly written it is.
5. About 98% of the jokes are people falling or spoofing a celebrity.
6. That it's responsible for American Dad.
7. That it came back and Futurama didn't.
8. They think rape is funny.
9. Stewie is a copy of Jimmy Corigan.
10. The flashbacks often have NOTHING to do with the stories. You can take all of the gags from one episode and swap them with another and someone who hasn't seen either episode before wouldn't know there was a difference.

[ferretchucker]

1. How inconsistent the characters are. Where the fuck did the "Everybody hates Meg" come from? Since when is Stewie gay?
2. Musical numbers. I get it, Seth is a good singer. An occasional one is fine, but fuck.
3. Exact recreations just replacing characters. Like the Dazed and Confused gag with Brian.
4. How badly written it is.
5. About 98% of the jokes are people falling or spoofing a celebrity.
6. That it's responsible for American Dad.
7. That it came back and Futurama didn't.
8. They think rape is funny.
9. Stewie is a copy of Jimmy Corigan.
10. The flashbacks often have NOTHING to do with the stories. You can take all of the gags from one episode and swap them with another and someone who hasn't seen either episode before wouldn't know there was a difference.

Those are the beauties of it (excluding number 8).

1. From the beginning, everyone at her school hated meg, it just slowly started shining through to the family. And Stewie has changed as he's aged. He's become a more pronounced character and he's becoming gay as time moves on. If you watch them in order it makes him gayer and gayer as time goes by, not just one episode he's suddenly a huge queer.

2. In relation to the amount of episodes there are, musical numbers aren't that many.

3. Well, they make people laugh.

4. Needs more backing up.

5. They do it well. They find something about them and caricature it, and the falling is always comical. Whether he's doing the drawing out the pain thing, which everybody knows somebody who does it, or they find a situation where it fits.

6. If it's good enough to get the creators to make a whole new show which too is loved by many, it's gotta be doing something right.

7. Blame Matt Groening and his team for that. They've got the power.

8. Fair enough point.

9. Care to elaborate?

10. That's their uniqueness. Better than having just an exact copy of another show. They decided to do something original and people like it for that.



@Freak - Yeh, that is a pretty good achievement. But not only did it do that, it did it twice.

[massacre man]

Those are the beauties of it (excluding number 8).

1. From the beginning, everyone at her school hated meg, it just slowly started shining through to the family. And Stewie has changed as he's aged. He's become a more pronounced character and he's becoming gay as time moves on. If you watch them in order it makes him gayer and gayer as time goes by, not just one episode he's suddenly a huge queer.

2. In relation to the amount of episodes there are, musical numbers aren't that many.

3. Well, they make people laugh.

4. Needs more backing up.

5. They do it well. They find something about them and caricature it, and the falling is always comical. Whether he's doing the drawing out the pain thing, which everybody knows somebody who does it, or they find a situation where it fits.

6. If it's good enough to get the creators to make a whole new show which too is loved by many, it's gotta be doing something right.

7. Blame Matt Groening and his team for that. They've got the power.

8. Fair enough point.

9. Care to elaborate?

10. That's their uniqueness. Better than having just an exact copy of another show. They decided to do something original and people like it for that.



@Freak - Yeh, that is a pretty good achievement. But not only did it do that, it did it twice.

1. In the beginning episode the family was sweet to Meg as soon as it came back on the air they were willing to let her die.

2. I'd say there's an average of at least 1 every 3 or 4 episodes.

3. Not me...

4. The episode where Lois got fat (really Lois in general is TERRIBLY written) "It's his fault I'm eating, he won't touch me!" We didn't need you to say that, we understood it the first time, and why is she saying to the rolls?

5.Are we watching the same show?

6. Just because something is popular doesn't mean it's good. Once again this is why I hate it. Not why I think other people should hate it.

7. No they don't...

8. ...

9. Google it.

10.They're unique for opting to use a terrible gimmick?
Jesus, arguing this is like the time I sat naked on the planes they hijacked on 9/11 with Connie Chung!
*Clip of me naked on a plane with Connie Chung*
Me: Hey Connie Chung! Want some tea?
Connie Chung...
*Cat leaps out of nowhere and scratches Connie Chung. Terrorist enters frame.*
*Musical number about terrorists and cats*

[Noah]

Good for you, too bad you have no taste.


If me hating Family Guy = me having no taste? I guess it IS too bad then.

[La Chat Noire]

I think Family Guy can be entertaining sometimes, but in my opinion it's a little overrated. South Park definitely fits my sense of humor more. I loved that they brought back the Woodland Critters for Imagination Land.

[neverending]

I'm not very fond of Family Guy either. I think Stewie is a great character, but overall the episodes only make me chuckle occasionally. Southpark gets the huge belly laughs from me, every episode. I love seeing who or what they're going to tackle each time. Hell, they even made fun of Chris Reeves.

[X¤MurderDoll¤X]

I fucking hate Family Guy, it's gaddamned garbage. South Park.

agreed.

imagination land

[Vodstok]

I loved family guy back when it first aired. The radnomness was new then, and South park was still more about shock value than anything. Family Guy accomplished something big when it was brought back, but it wound up like pet semetary, what came back was changed (some would say evil). Now it is a mindless zombie compared to what it was.

In contrast, South Park has matured. their balls have grown, and so has their insightfulness.I am impressed that they can still shock me, jaded as i am. Watch Stanley's Cup (season 11 finale), the end caught me completely of guard.
Plus, it is just about the only thing that can come close to offend me in my adult life. I love that.