Past number 3

[Vodstok]

I was just reading a friday the 13th thread and realized something: there appears to be a rule of three with a lot of movie series. Look at any horror series that isnt specifically a trilogy.

The first is often loved. The second is often looked at with equal parts, better than the first, not wuite as good as the first, and as good as the first, but in all cas3es, usually well regarded.

By the time we get to the third installment, things change. Usually this is the one that is split down the middle, people either hate it or love it.

Past the third, they are generally regarded as shit. Some examples:


Alien: Masterpiece
Aliens: Masterpiece
Alien3: Some of us love it, saying it brings back the feel of the first, others just hated it.

it seems that the friday the 13th movies are similar, with many people liking the fiorst 3 and just despising the rest. I have heard similar things about the Nightmare on Elmstreet movies. Hellraiser 1 and 2 seem to be favorites, with 3 splitting people down the middle (no pun intended) and the rest not being too terribly popular.


Of course, there are exceptions, tremors was a cool movie, but 2 and 3 were just stupid.

[Roderick Usher]

Star Wars falls solidly into this one

A New Hope - Classic
Empire Stikes Back - Masterpiece
Return of the Jedi - Lame kiddie flick

Attack of the Clones - pure shit, a rape of my childhood dreams
Clone Wars - sacchrine
Revenge of the Sith - :mad:

as does The Godfather
Godfather - Brilliant
Godfather II - Even Better!
Godfather III - WTF?

[The Flayed One]

One of my favorite trilogies fits this formula as well

Ginger Snaps - Classic
Ginger Snaps Unleashed - Great, some like it better than the first
Ginger Snaps Back - Some love it, others hate it. No one says it's as good as the first two.

[Zero]

Silence of the Lambs - Masterpiece
Hannibal - divided; some loved, some hated
Red Dragon - utter and total shite

(of course if we include Mann's Manhunter we get a different picture:
Manhunter - cult classic, though universally hated when it came out)
SOL - oscar winning masterpiece
Hannibal - some loved some hated
Red Dragon - even bigger piece of utter and total shit

[Despare]

I think there are some people who aren't able to accept a movie past "Number 3" as a good movie no matter what happens. There's just so much of the tireless crying about movie sequels these days that I feel some movies don't get a fair shot. Anyway, one for the formula...

Evil Dead
Evil Dead 2
Army of Darkness

(Although I loved all 3)

[Vodstok]

I think there are some people who aren't able to accept a movie past "Number 3" as a good movie no matter what happens. There's just so much of the tireless crying about movie sequels these days that I feel some movies don't get a fair shot. Anyway, one for the formula...

Evil Dead
Evil Dead 2
Army of Darkness

(Although I loved all 3)

Same here, but AOD rarely gets the love the first 2 get.

[paws the great]

Psycho (1960)- Loved by all.

Psycho 2 - Most people like this one.

Psycho 3 - Alot of people do not like.

I love them all.:D

[ManchestrMorgue]

Jaws - masterpiece
Jaws 2 - good movie, if not at the same level as the original
Jaws 3 - not even 3D could make your mother love you.

[BlackSunProductions]

Jurassic Park
The Lost World: Jurassic Park 2
Jurassic Park III

Speilberg should have never done three if there wasn't a third book.

[Vodstok]

Jurassic Park
The Lost World: Jurassic Park 2
Jurassic Park III

Speilberg should have never done three if there wasn't a third book.

2 REALLY should have stuck more to the book, and Julianne Moore was a horrible choice for Sarah...


I actually like 3 better than 2.

[urgeok]

- Matrix - fantastic
- matrix 2 - crap
- matrix 3 - crap

- Terminator - great
- terminator 2 - great
- terminator 3 - just shy of great

- blade - ok
- blade 2 - great
- blade 3 - shit

- superman - great
- superman 2 - not bad
- superman 3 - poop
- superman 4 - corn in the poo

- harry potter - great
- harry potter 2 - great
- harry potter 3 - not so great
- harry potter 4 - great
(fuck it - i like the harry potters)

[The Mothman]

arded as shit. Some examples:


Alien: Masterpiece
Aliens: Masterpiece
Alien3: Some of us love it, saying it brings back the feel of the first, others just hated it.



i dont care what anyone says. money-grubbing Alien Ressurection friggin rocked.

[Vodstok]

i dont care what anyone says. money-grubbing Alien Ressurection friggin rocked.

I will always maintain that it succeeded as a scifi horror movie, but failed miserably as an alien flick. Proof that great casat and great direction can fail with a shit script (fuck you Joss Whedon)

[Roderick Usher]

- harry potter - great
- harry potter 2 - great
- harry potter 3 - not so great
- harry potter 4 - great
(fuck it - i like the harry potters)


WHAAAAA?

#3 was the only one that didn't feel like it was made by a muggle - the best of the lot by a long shot

[_____V_____]

Scream - good
Scream 2 - alrite
Scream 3 - crap


Saw - fantastic
Saw 2 - disappointing
Saw 3 - better


Final Destination - gold
Final Destination 2 - watchable
Final Destination 3 - crap


Child's Play - fascinating
Child's Play 2 - average
Child's Play 3 - watchable
Child's Play 4: Bride of Chucky - good
Child's Play 5: Seed of Chucky - crap


Batman - great
Batman Returns - fantastic
Batman Forever - tolerable
Batman & Robin - ridiculous


The Omen - fantastic
Damien: Omen II - watchable
Omen III: The Final Conflict - disappointing
Omen IV: The Awakening - crap


X-Men - pure genius
X2: X-Men United - good
X3: X-Men The Last Stand - average


Night of the Living Dead - brilliant
Dawn of the Dead - fantastic
Day of the Dead - awesome
Land of the Dead - average

[urgeok]

WHAAAAA?

#3 was the only one that didn't feel like it was made by a muggle - the best of the lot by a long shot

not from where i stand..

it failed to capture the soul of the series ..the interraction of the kids - the character developement..

#3 just rushed along from action sequence to action sequence.

its a childrens book series, - The Hardy Boys with magic - not a goth-boy's wet dream..

[The Mothman]

I will always maintain that it succeeded as a scifi horror movie, but failed miserably as an alien flick. Proof that great casat and great direction can fail with a shit script (fuck you Joss Whedon)
right, it couldnt really compare to the first two, however it was tons of fun. I remeber seeing it when i was really little, and being super stoked. I had never realy seen a gory movie before that.