Log in

View Full Version : It all sucks


halloweenfreak1
08-13-2006, 04:27 PM
horror movies from japan suck(just my take)

azathoth777
08-13-2006, 07:41 PM
Maybe you're just not seeing the right ones...

Morbid Fantasy
08-13-2006, 07:54 PM
Ju-On and ringu basically put me off of Japanese horror movies.

Angelakillsluts
08-13-2006, 07:59 PM
Originally posted by halloweenfreak1
horror movies from japan suck(just my take)

lmao

azathoth777
08-13-2006, 09:37 PM
Originally posted by Morbid Fantasy
Ju-On and ringu basically put me off of Japanese horror movies.

But not all Japanese horror is like that. There's alot of other styles of horror that's just as good as US movies.

Angra
08-14-2006, 01:08 AM
Originally posted by Morbid Fantasy
Ju-On and ringu basically put me off of Japanese horror movies.



I don“t like you anymore..

urgeok
08-14-2006, 07:48 AM
nothing like a well thought out - well explained point of view.

dead thread.

Vodstok
08-14-2006, 08:28 AM
No way, Japanese horror sux yo!

Actually, Im not a big fan ingeneral, but I liked the ring. So iguess i like at least 1 movie made from a japanese horror flick..
Audition was good too.

The Grudge with Buffy? Now, that was a festering vat of puss....

urgeok
08-14-2006, 08:29 AM
Originally posted by Vodstok
No way, Japanese horror sux yo!

Actually, Im not a big fan ingeneral, but I liked the ring. So iguess i like at least 1 movie made from a japanese horror flick..
Audition was good too.

The Grudge with Buffy? Now, that was a festering vat of puss....

you dont know shit, spamwhore !!!!

Vodstok
08-14-2006, 08:49 AM
Originally posted by urgeok
you dont know shit, spamwhore !!!! LOL!

Am i treading on your turf?


You're like Vincent Schiavelli in ghost. "What are you doing here?!?! THis is MY TRAIN!"

urgeok
08-14-2006, 08:51 AM
Originally posted by Vodstok
LOL!

Am i treading on your turf?


You're like Vincent Schiavelli in ghost. "What are you doing here?!?! THis is MY TRAIN!"


exactly ...


"not on my watch boy !!"


::p

Vodstok
08-14-2006, 08:56 AM
Well, it had the intended effect, people started posting a lot more :)


My work here is done.

this house, is clear.

urgeok
08-14-2006, 09:00 AM
Originally posted by Vodstok
Well, it had the intended effect, people started posting a lot more :)


My work here is done.

this house, is clear.

great quality stuff too !

Phalanx
08-14-2006, 10:14 AM
Uzumaki, dark water, Wild Zero, Versus, Ichi, mister vampire...They are each a different style, each a different kind of what you could broadly call "horror" although some are more psychological thriller...either way, there's not a whole bunch wrong with those, and then there's the multitude of horror animated features, some truly aweful, some brilliant.
The first ring was great IMO, but should've been left as was.
Personally, I just think you need to watch more before casting the blanket judgement.

zwoti
08-15-2006, 10:37 AM
Originally posted by Phalanx
mister vampire


hong kong

urgeok
08-15-2006, 11:06 AM
Originally posted by zwoti
newb has a nice ass

jesus, there he goes again !

The STE
08-15-2006, 11:10 AM
the lead singer to the New Radicals kinda looked like Moby

PR3SSUR3
08-22-2006, 04:12 AM
Perhaps he is referring to the concept of 'J-Horror', which in general has a distinctive psychological, folk-religious slant.

I agree this kind of thing is becoming overly familiar, and one of the reasons for its wearing out could be a lack of identification Westerners have with Asian film stars and heroes. In many cases, it's just another interchangeable careerwoman/single mother/teenager faced with a supernatural dilemma only the 'understanding' of a mysterious legend can sort out.

'J-Gore' (:D) is home to some pretty cool movies, but again I think the disturbing effects left on us by Hostel, Saw even Haute Tension are far more significant through identification and, also, style - the Japs have a tendency to apply ridiculous sound effects and theatrics to some of their scenes of violence which causes less intensity and more sense of awe. This might have worked well for Italian exploitation, but Asian stuff seems somehow more removed from sense and logic.

Lala_Sound
08-22-2006, 05:16 AM
Hmm fair enough if you dont like J-horror but TBH it seemed a pretty immature thing to do. If you don't like it don't come on this thread isn't that an easier idea? :]

XtRaVa
08-22-2006, 05:25 AM
Bloody lame.

urgeok
08-22-2006, 05:43 PM
Originally posted by Lala_Sound
Hmm fair enough if you dont like J-horror but TBH it seemed a pretty immature thing to do. If you don't like it don't come on this thread isn't that an easier idea? :]


i personally dont at all mind someones critique of j-horror.
its a forum, if someone has an opinion that can be expressed in words better than 'it all sucks' then they ar emore than welcome as far as i'm concerned.

Lala_Sound
08-23-2006, 12:01 PM
Originally posted by urgeok
i personally dont at all mind someones critique of j-horror.
its a forum, if someone has an opinion that can be expressed in words better than 'it all sucks' then they ar emore than welcome as far as i'm concerned.

Well I agree but the way he put it was pretty indescriptive and seemed kind of pointless that was why I couldnt understand why he had to write it :]

Roderick Usher
08-23-2006, 02:38 PM
Watch WILD ZERO!!!!!!

Japanese rockabilly zombie-hunting transvestite love story.

"Ace-a! Rock n Roll!"

PR3SSUR3
08-23-2006, 07:33 PM
This is Rock'n'Roll Jet Movie?

halloweenfreak1
08-25-2006, 06:22 PM
Originally posted by urgeok
pretty limp way to express yourself ..

at least have the maturity to explain why you dont like them.

the reson i dont like them is that they are not scary. The story line is there but the thrill that are in the american movies isn't. I'm sure im not the only one with this opinion.

halloweenfreak1
08-25-2006, 06:25 PM
Originally posted by Lala_Sound
Well I agree but the way he put it was pretty indescriptive and seemed kind of pointless that was why I couldnt understand why he had to write it :]

sorry if you are offended. and i understand that i didnt stick with this thread long enough to explain myself.

Lala_Sound
08-26-2006, 01:18 AM
Originally posted by halloweenfreak1
sorry if you are offended. and i understand that i didnt stick with this thread long enough to explain myself.

You didn't offend me I can understand and respect that people dislike the genre of movies that I like but I just couldn't understand why you felt the need to post a thread just saying "it sucks" I was like well that helps

halloweenfreak1
08-26-2006, 03:31 AM
Originally posted by Lala_Sound
You didn't offend me I can understand and respect that people dislike the genre of movies that I like but I just couldn't understand why you felt the need to post a thread just saying "it sucks" I was like well that helps

the reason i did that was so i could get people in my thread . it caught your eye didnt it. that was the point behind that.

Lala_Sound
08-27-2006, 12:10 PM
So you did it so that people would notice you?

MichaelMyers63
08-27-2006, 05:20 PM
Originally posted by halloweenfreak1
horror movies from japan suck(just my take)

the grudge was a wonderful film.

halloweenfreak1
08-27-2006, 05:23 PM
Originally posted by Lala_Sound
So you did it so that people would notice you?

No, i did it so i would get a response, but it dosnt matter anymore i got the point across :D

halloweenfreak1
08-27-2006, 05:24 PM
Originally posted by MichaelMyers63
the grudge was a wonderful film.

yeah it was , if you're 12

urgeok
08-27-2006, 06:13 PM
Originally posted by halloweenfreak1
yeah it was , if you're 12


i'm 45 - it's one of my all time favorites.

Lala_Sound
08-28-2006, 12:32 AM
I also happen to adore The Grudge :]

Still confused.

urgeok
08-28-2006, 05:05 AM
Originally posted by halloweenfreak1
the reason i did that was so i could get people in my thread . it caught your eye didnt it. that was the point behind that.

the point of a thread is to make a point ..share some knowledge, or have fun.


your thread was a troll thread and it brings the intelligence level of an already suffering forum even lower.

zwoti
08-28-2006, 05:36 AM
Originally posted by urgeok
the point of a thread is to make a point ..share some knowledge, or have fun.


your thread was a troll thread and it brings the intelligence level of an already suffering forum even lower.

my brain hurtz

urgeok
08-28-2006, 05:38 AM
Originally posted by zwoti
my brain hurtz

Burning in Hell
08-29-2006, 12:28 PM
Well, actually, I'm not that fond of J-Movies either I must say.

I think the main problem for me is that, and I think I can make an analogy with Italian movies here, there are often very cheesy moments in these films, and that the acting is often severly overdone. I guess it's a matter of some cultural elements that are somewhat "lost in translation" and that prevent me from getting into these movies in general.

I don't prentend to be an expert on Asian movies, but I have nonetheless seen 50 of these or so, since I like to keep updated and am still hoping I will be won over by these someday. And I have to say I have found some really interesting films from that part of the world (Dark Waters, Shutter, The Eye/The Eye 2), but that, in the majority, I did not particularly like movies like the Ringu and Ju-Hon movies, Pulse, etc.

Just my two cents on the subject...

halloweenfreak1
08-30-2006, 03:24 PM
Originally posted by Burning in Hell
Well, actually, I'm not that fond of J-Movies either I must say.

I think the main problem for me is that, and I think I can make an analogy with Italian movies here, there are often very cheesy moments in these films, and that the acting is often severly overdone. I guess it's a matter of some cultural elements that are somewhat "lost in translation" and that prevent me from getting into these movies in general.

I don't prentend to be an expert on Asian movies, but I have nonetheless seen 50 of these or so, since I like to keep updated and am still hoping I will be won over by these someday. And I have to say I have found some really interesting films from that part of the world (Dark Waters, Shutter, The Eye/The Eye 2), but that, in the majority, I did not particularly like movies like the Ringu and Ju-Hon movies, Pulse, etc.

Just my two cents on the subject...

thank you

halloweenfreak1
08-30-2006, 03:26 PM
Originally posted by urgeok
the point of a thread is to make a point ..share some knowledge, or have fun.


your thread was a troll thread and it brings the intelligence level of an already suffering forum even lower.

are you saying i'm stupid?

bloodrayne
08-30-2006, 03:35 PM
Originally posted by halloweenfreak1
horror movies from japan suck(just my take) Wow...You've seen EVERY Japanese horror movie ever made???!!!....That's absolutely AMAZING...

I'm surprised you didn't like 3 Extremes...That was really good...The Eye was great, too...


Why on earth would you watch SO many Japanese movies, if you didn't like them?...I think I would have stopped after about the first 100 or so...


Oh well...I guess you were just trying to keep an open mind...Sorry it didn't work out for you...

halloweenfreak1
08-30-2006, 03:52 PM
Originally posted by bloodrayne
Wow...You've seen EVERY Japanese horror movie ever made???!!!....That's absolutely AMAZING...

I'm surprised you didn't like 3 Extremes...That was really good...The Eye was great, too...


Why on earth would you watch SO many Japanese movies, if you didn't like them?...I think I would have stopped after about the first 100 or so...


Oh well...I guess you were just trying to keep an open mind...Sorry it didn't work out for you...

lol, no i have not seen them all. i just didnt like the ones i saw

bloodrayne
08-30-2006, 04:39 PM
Originally posted by halloweenfreak1
lol, no i have not seen them all. i just didnt like the ones i saw Oh...Well...That makes a lot more sense than saying they ALL suck...

noctuary
08-30-2006, 05:33 PM
This is kinda like me deciding that all Italian horror flicks suck after watching Cemetary Man.

urgeok
08-31-2006, 06:11 AM
Originally posted by halloweenfreak1
are you saying i'm stupid?


i cant comment on you personally -

but a lot of your posts sure are.

halloweenfreak1
08-31-2006, 04:56 PM
Originally posted by urgeok
i cant comment on you personally -

but a lot of your posts sure are.

o well i guess i have a very different view of things.lots of my friends disagree to. but i do have people who agree.

halloweenfreak1
08-31-2006, 05:02 PM
Originally posted by omcdave
hay ween what movies if any do you like then? they most be relly great compared to this suck ass asian shit we like. so start typing.

milo was one of my favorites.. Ilike the last sign,halloween, NoES ,F13,jeepers creepers, the fog(the original), red riding hood(which i am like the only person who likes it i think), hell raiser , they , and alot of others.

Lala_Sound
09-01-2006, 11:19 AM
Originally posted by Burning in Hell
Well, actually, I'm not that fond of J-Movies either I must say.

I think the main problem for me is that, and I think I can make an analogy with Italian movies here, there are often very cheesy moments in these films, and that the acting is often severly overdone. I guess it's a matter of some cultural elements that are somewhat "lost in translation" and that prevent me from getting into these movies in general.

I don't prentend to be an expert on Asian movies, but I have nonetheless seen 50 of these or so, since I like to keep updated and am still hoping I will be won over by these someday. And I have to say I have found some really interesting films from that part of the world (Dark Waters, Shutter, The Eye/The Eye 2), but that, in the majority, I did not particularly like movies like the Ringu and Ju-Hon movies, Pulse, etc.

Just my two cents on the subject...

see this person isn't too bad because they explain the reasons why

heebiejeebies
09-03-2006, 02:20 PM
Originally posted by Duncanature
J-Horror is great. All these American remakes are slowly killing it, though. Americans can't stand the fact that the Japanese are better than them at anything, but by remaking all these movies, all they're doing is proving them right.

Let me start by saying I really enjoy J-horror, so the fact I'm biased in this case should be pretty obvious. I don't, however, see how American remakes of J-horror flicks can kill J-horror because people who are "true" fans of the genre are going to stick with it, meaning the foreign originals.

I think American audiences have a hard time with J-horror (and foreign horror in general) because we lack the cultural background to fully understand what is going on.

I loved The Ring when I saw it, but when I watched Ringu, I was smitten. I liked the Japanese version much better because it made sense. All of the paranormal, psychic stuff that was absent from the American version helped make Ringu cohesive. In fact, after watching Ringu I better understood The Ring, and I thought I had The Ring figured out. I do, however, understand why all of that stuff was absent from The Ring. American audiences and culture don't buy into paranormal phenomena like Asian cultures do, so the studio execs felt it needed to be toned down.

That being said, I do agree with Duncanature that American cinema has overdone the whole "J-horror ripoff" thing, just as it's overdone the remake/"reimagining" thing. It becomes laughable when the list of movies at the cineplex reads like a movie list from the 70's: Wicker Man, When a Stranger Calls, The Hills Have Eyes, Texas Chainsaw Massacre, The Omen, The Fog, etc. It's even more laughable when you realize that the 70's originals are millions of times better (with the possible exception of THHE).

Of course even quality directors like Scorsese aren't above doing it. The Departed (his latest cinematic "masterpiece") is just the Americanized version of Infernal Affairs, which is one hell of a movie.

Sorry to have climbed on my soapbox, but this is something that really gets me hot under the collar.

heebiejeebies
09-03-2006, 03:09 PM
Originally posted by Duncanature
I didn't mean it would "kill it off" actually. But all these remakes could turn some Americans off to J-horror. I'm sure the true fans will continue to be true fans. I know I will. I just think Americans should stop trying to be Japanese and continue to do good, high-quality American horror films. Just because a horror movie is made in America doesn't mean it's any better or worse than a J-horror movie. The Japanese may be better at ghost movies, but they have yet to top us in the zombie or slasher genre.

I see what you mean, and I agree that American horror should stand on its own two feet.

XtRaVa
09-03-2006, 03:49 PM
(First of all no offense to anyone here thats american etc, I dont mean any..)

Americans think that they can take an asian horror, and make it much better by adding some special effects and CGI...we all know americans like things to be bigger and more fantastical.

Asian horror generally doesnt have amazing effects, but they dont need effects because they work on scaring the viewer psychologically, rather than with other the top effects. It often works a lot on what you dont see, and that is in actual fact a lot scarier most of the time.

These days asian horror is getting a lot wealthier, but I still never expect them to have the amount of effects hollywood studios use, because they dont NEED or WANT them in their movies to scare people, and to produce high quality horror.

Instead they use original (although often based on folk-law and ghost legends) and wonderfully creative stories to sell there movies instead. Coupled with characters you can actually sympathise with, backed up with actors who arent just in it for the money.

American movie companies are trying to cash in on these films by re-making them, simply because they cant create any original movies of their own.

They also realise that many of the movie go-ers would never of seen the original before, because lets face it they are usually ignorant to other cultures, or at least dont have the patience to experience anything other than what they are used to. In this case, with horror movies, another teen slasher flick, with lots of sex and gore.

I for one wish they would try and diversify without having to re-make movies which I am very fond of.

XtRaVa
09-03-2006, 04:26 PM
You mean Kairo, Pulse is the name of the bad american re-make. It hardly had any CGI really. Like in the american one they had to show the guy like being pulled into the wall as though it was evil, but they totally missed the point.

In the J version they just disapear to a black space, because its all about being alone, as though even some living are just ghosts fading into the background. It was a big metaphor thing, supposed to make us think...but americans had to make out as though there was some evil force trying to kill the living...

XtRaVa
09-03-2006, 05:25 PM
:D Good man!

halloweenfreak1
09-06-2006, 04:38 PM
Originally posted by XtRaVa
(First of all no offense to anyone here thats american etc, I dont mean any..)

Americans think that they can take an asian horror, and make it much better by adding some special effects and CGI...we all know americans like things to be bigger and more fantastical.

Asian horror generally doesnt have amazing effects, but they dont need effects because they work on scaring the viewer psychologically, rather than with other the top effects. It often works a lot on what you dont see, and that is in actual fact a lot scarier most of the time.

These days asian horror is getting a lot wealthier, but I still never expect them to have the amount of effects hollywood studios use, because they dont NEED or WANT them in their movies to scare people, and to produce high quality horror.

Instead they use original (although often based on folk-law and ghost legends) and wonderfully creative stories to sell there movies instead. Coupled with characters you can actually sympathise with, backed up with actors who arent just in it for the money.

American movie companies are trying to cash in on these films by re-making them, simply because they cant create any original movies of their own.

They also realise that many of the movie go-ers would never of seen the original before, because lets face it they are usually ignorant to other cultures, or at least dont have the patience to experience anything other than what they are used to. In this case, with horror movies, another teen slasher flick, with lots of sex and gore.

I for one wish they would try and diversify without having to re-make movies which I am very fond of.

All very good points. I also agree with the whole special effects thing. Totally not scary. the greatest american scary movies didnt have that many holly wood effects(outside of NoES). But you can't say that J-Horror is original if most of them are about ghosts. Now im not a true fan as you say. I have probubly not seen half of the films you have. But the ones i saw didnt apeal to me(they sucked, no offence they just wernt all i hoped they would be).

PR3SSUR3
09-07-2006, 05:58 AM
the japanse pulse is very slow by that is what makes it work

Pffft! If by slow you mean brain-numbing, pronderous tedium then I don't think it works at all.

Also, the CGI is very obvious and poor.

For once, I'm looking forward to a zippier, flashy American remake.

urgeok
09-07-2006, 06:17 AM
Originally posted by PR3SSUR3
Pffft! If by slow you mean brain-numbing, pronderous tedium then I don't think it works at all.

Also, the CGI is very obvious and poor.

For once, I'm looking forward to a zippier, flashy American remake.

i can feel the love :D

XtRaVa
09-07-2006, 08:21 AM
Originally posted by PR3SSUR3
Pffft! If by slow you mean brain-numbing, pronderous tedium then I don't think it works at all.

Also, the CGI is very obvious and poor.

For once, I'm looking forward to a zippier, flashy American remake.

Thats fair enough, but in that case you're just waiting for an american horror movie not a japanese horror movie. They've made it into a film where the dead are seemingly evil and all after the living, jumping out of washing machines and such.

The guy who fades into the black is taken against his will by something evil, when this wasnt the point of the original. In the original the people realise they are lonely, and no better than the dead, scared of their fate but willing to except that even in death they will be alone. Then they fade away to nothing. A big metaphor for all those people sitting alone at their pc's who arent better than the dead...alone with not much reason to live.

The american remake has made it as though everyones going to get taken away by an evil force and by monsterous ghosts running about etc. Thats fine if thats the sort of thing you want to see, but its actually quite far from what the original was trying to do. I agree it would be zippier etc, with a lot more obvious frights and jumps, but thats just classic hollywood horror.

I like american horrors for what they are, I also like japanese horrors for what they are. The mixing of the two never seems to work, and only lessens the two types of horror...In my opinion they shouldnt mix just to line movie companies pockets with money.

halloweenfreak1
12-31-2006, 01:59 PM
I see what you mean, and I agree that American horror should stand on its own two feet.
has every one forgotten all of the huge american horror movies? exorcist? halloween? ringing any bells?

XtRaVa
01-01-2007, 09:00 AM
Exorcist in my opinion is over-rated, but still a good movie and a must watch before you die. Halloween is great because Michael Myers is such a legendary horror icon (hell I dressed up as him on halloween with my deluxe mask :D).

The point is american horror movies are usually slashers, and monsters. Asian horrors, especially J-Horror is usually based around ghost stories and freaky stuff like that (not a strict rule of thumb or anything for both nations horror productions, but generally speaking).

halloweenfreak1
01-01-2007, 01:52 PM
but its the slasher films that americans have come to know and love, all of the legendary american horrors excluding the excorcist and hell raiser are slasher films.

halloweenfreak1
01-01-2007, 01:54 PM
the point to my rambling is that american horror can indeed stand on its own two feet. it just needs to stick with the original slasher type films.

Geddy
01-01-2007, 01:57 PM
but its the slasher films that americans have come to know and love, all of the legendary american horrors excluding the excorcist and hell raiser are slasher films.

No they're not,There are tons of legendary american movies that are'nt slashers or the excorcist or hellraiser.

XtRaVa
01-01-2007, 02:14 PM
the point to my rambling is that american horror can indeed stand on its own two feet. it just needs to stick with the original slasher type films.

Yeah it can. Thats why it annoys me when they just make re-makes of existing asian horror, and even just bad remakes of original american horrors just because the new american youth (and england too (I went out in my deluxe Michael Myers mask, and girls in their teens and 20's were asking who I was...............Ridiculous but true)) are too ignorant and lazy to see the originals (or even know of them), so they re-make it with good looking men and women who play 17 year olds.

They should stick to what they know, but try and be original at the same time, not just rip-off other movies, or churn out re-makes...

XtRaVa
01-01-2007, 05:00 PM
Yeah, I mean I watched the original Halloween the other day, and I have to admit it was very slow by todays standards and therefore almost boring. But I still remember how good it was the first time I watched it, and it will always be a classic.

halloweenfreak1
01-01-2007, 10:25 PM
Yeah it can. Thats why it annoys me when they just make re-makes of existing asian horror, and even just bad remakes of original american horrors just because the new american youth (and england too (I went out in my deluxe Michael Myers mask, and girls in their teens and 20's were asking who I was...............Ridiculous but true)) are too ignorant and lazy to see the originals (or even know of them), so they re-make it with good looking men and women who play 17 year olds.

They should stick to what they know, but try and be original at the same time, not just rip-off other movies, or churn out re-makes...
I couldnt have said it better myself

slayer666
01-02-2007, 04:20 AM
When one considers Italian giallo films, I'm not sure how original the American slashers were. Personally, I'll take Bava and Argento films over most of the American slashers.

halloweenfreak1
01-02-2007, 11:16 AM
there is really only a few core movies america made that became legend. there are many good films but only a few great.

urgeok
01-02-2007, 11:55 AM
When one considers Italian giallo films, I'm not sure how original the American slashers were. Personally, I'll take Bava and Argento films over most of the American slashers.


i think the italian slashers owe a lot to the american ones.
the italians (technically) did it first but never had the critical acclaim and exposure that the americans had ('halloween' blew 'bay of blood' out of the water for the impact it had worldwide)


There several italian ripoffs of Halloween, and The Exorcist, and Escape from New York.

It wasnt until years after seeing the inferior rip offs of american films that i began to realize that a lot of other films origionated in Italy ... notuntil i began to delve into the genre a lot deeper.

the casual viewer has no idea the italian films exist.
I'm willing to bet the more people in italy know Halloween than they do Bay of Blood. Everyone wants the american product.

i'm not saying this is the ideal situation - but it's reality

slayer666
01-02-2007, 12:28 PM
i think the italian slashers owe a lot to the american ones.
the italians (technically) did it first but never had the critical acclaim and exposure that the americans had ('halloween' blew 'bay of blood' out of the water for the impact it had worldwide)

In addition to doing it first, I'd argue that the Italians (and Canadians - Black Christmas) did it better. I don't judge the value of a film solely on the basis of box office returns. Halloween was certainly more popular but wouldn't have been possible without Black Christmas, Twitch of the Death Nerve, and some others.

I agree completely that the American films have done a great service by getting people interested in the genre, leading them to experience foreign films. It certainly worked that way for me.

Remakes do tend to piss me off, however, I suppose I could try to view all the American remakes of Asian horror as flattery rather than just exploitation.

halloweenfreak1
01-02-2007, 01:03 PM
In addition to doing it first, I'd argue that the Italians (and Canadians - Black Christmas) did it better. I don't judge the value of a film solely on the basis of box office returns. Halloween was certainly more popular but wouldn't have been possible without Black Christmas, Twitch of the Death Nerve, and some others.

I agree completely that the American films have done a great service by getting people interested in the genre, leading them to experience foreign films. It certainly worked that way for me.

Remakes do tend to piss me off, however, I suppose I could try to view all the American remakes of Asian horror as flattery rather than just exploitation.
so really what you are saying is that american films are good only as warm up films so you can be lead on to bigger and better foreign films. If so i would have to disagree entirely. Black Christmas was one of my all time favorites, so you cant call me bias, but Halloween was better in every way shape and form in my perspective.

XtRaVa
01-02-2007, 04:50 PM
i think the italian slashers owe a lot to the american ones.
the italians (technically) did it first.

A guy called Alfred Hitchcock did it first in a little movie called Psycho...and he was English ;)

The movie is defined as technically the first slasher movie and influenced the modern slasher films such as Halloween.

slayer666
01-03-2007, 02:56 AM
A guy called Alfred Hitchcock did it first in a little movie called Psycho...and he was English ;)

Maybe Psycho can be considered the first slasher film. I'm not sure I would agree with that. Regardless, I have read that Psycho was influenced by Les Diabolique (1954) and Dead of Night (1945).

XtRaVa
01-03-2007, 06:34 AM
I was watching one of those all time top horror and thriller film thingies on the TV. Many well known horror directors listed it, and went on to say how it spawned the slasher genre and influenced their films. Wes Craven and John Carpenter were two of those guys.

But yeah I expect even Psycho had influences, and those influences had influences too :)

halloweenfreak1
01-03-2007, 06:59 AM
I was watching one of those all time top horror and thriller film thingies on the TV. Many well known horror directors listed it, and went on to say how it spawned the slasher genre and influenced their films. Wes Craven and John Carpenter were two of those guys.

But yeah I expect even Psycho had influences, and those influences had influences too :)

im sure most early films were influenced by true stories that were just tweaked a little bit.

urgeok
01-03-2007, 07:38 AM
slasher movies are a no brainer really - as far as the core influences/inspirations come from.

what scares people ... the thought of someone killing you.

what scares you in a film : the technique used to present this to you.

technique is the only real measurable when it comes to who influence who.

so i would say yes - hitchcock perfected the technique of suspense in a horror film,

the others that followed each put their own little tweak on it ..

Bay of Blood = brutality
Halloween = the killer who couldnt be killed
Black Christmas = the killer inside your house..

etc etc ..

the ones that stand out and became popular are the ones who had their own unique angle.

(more atmospheric music, better performances, more inventive kills)

XtRaVa
01-03-2007, 08:58 AM
Yeah. God bless that the genre was created thats all I can say :)

halloweenfreak1
01-05-2007, 09:02 PM
in my perspective slashers are the best type of horror out there.