I see dead people - for a
modest fee.
Director Kiyoshi Kurosawa
has achieved some modest notoriety in the West recently for films like
Doppelganger (Dopperugenga) and Bright Future (Akarui
Mirai) -- both of which were distinctly better than Seance
(Korei). A generic "couple haunted by dead child" story, Seance
nevertheless has a promising first half before collapsing from the illogical
actions of its characters, then serves up an abrupt finish that leaves far more
questions than answers.
Koji Yakusho plays Sato, a
sound effects engineer working for a film production company in Tokyo. He lives
with his long-time girlfriend Junko (Jun Fubuki), a medium who works part-time
as a waitress and gives psychic readings to clients out of her and Sato's home.
But Junko is a bit freaked out because she sees dead people -- and this being a
Japanese horror film, the kind of dead people she sees are usually of the female
variety with long black hair hanging in front of their faces. When she begins to
see them at her job (a young dead woman inexplicably follows one of her
customers around), she suddenly quits, afraid to leave the house for fear of
seeing some new specter wherever she goes.
However, when a young girl
is kidnapped, a police detective turns to her for help. After examining some of
the girl's things, she tells the detective that she believes the child to be
alive. Meanwhile, as her husband is out in the woods recording nature sounds,
the girl in question happens upon his van as she is running away from her
abductor. She hides in an empty equipment case that Sato has left on the ground
next to the van, in an effort to shake her pursuer, only to become locked inside
instead. It is at this point that the film begins to unravel.
Setting aside the wildly
improbable coincidence of the same girl that Junko is looking for ending up
inside of Sato's equipment case, one has to ask "If Sato left an empty equipment
case outside of his van, wouldn't he immediately find the girl inside when he
came back to his van to put his equipment away?" In any kind of logical world,
this would make eminent sense, yet Sato merely closes the empty case and puts it
back in the van (apparently having left his equipment back in the woods, and of
course never once stopping to wonder why an empty case was so heavy). He then
takes the case home, unknowing the entire time that there is a girl inside, then
pulls it out of the van and leaves it on the garage floor -- all without ever
once looking inside.
When Junko has a psychic
premonition that the girl is very close by, and she and Sato find her in the
case, barely alive after near-suffocation, it seems that the likely course of
action would be to call the police, at which point the girl could explain to
them how she ended up in Sato's trunk. Case closed, right? Wrong. That would be
the logical conclusion, however Junko gets an idea to plant the girl somewhere
else and then tell the police where she is, so that she can gain notoriety as a
famous psychic who helped find the missing girl. Sato agrees to help her at
first, however, this idiotic plan backfires on them with tragic results, and
soon after they are repeatedly haunted by ghostly manifestations.
Although Seance has
some wonderful moments of creepiness and plenty of spooky atmosphere, the
constant gaps of logic and the far-fetched actions of the characters end up
being a major distraction. In addition to Sato and Junko doing highly illogical
things, the film also raises several questions that go un-answered, only to wrap
things up with an abruptness that is mismatched with the slow yet methodical
pacing in the film's first half. Who was the dead girl that Junko kept seeing at
the restaurant? What was up with the mysterious voice that Sato hears on one of
his sound effects tapes? Unfortunately, these are just a couple of the types of
questions that Seance poses, and then ignores.
Although there are some
admittedly eerie scenes in Seance, and uniformly good performances from
Yakusho and Fubuki, the film suffers from a lack of consistency and a slew of
illogical character actions that ring so false that Seance fails to fully
engage on any level beyond the momentary and visceral. If the mere presence of a
ghostly child with scraggly hair is enough to keep you entertained,
Seance might be up your alley. Anyone expecting much beyond that is
likely to be disappointed. |