And your next Top 100 compilation is...

[_____V_____]

We have pretty much covered all known bases of the horror genre, except for a few. Going through the Compilations when I was doing the image-link updation (for almost all of them), I was struck with 2 separate compilation ideas.

Top 100 Horror Movie Soundtracks

and

Top 100 Non-Horror Films


For the Movie Soundtracks, I doubt if we will have 100 OST albums defining quality, depth and popularity equally in the genre. So it would be better to go with a top 100 list of individual/single soundtracks than entire OST albums. What say?

For the Non-Horrors, all of us have proved time and again that we love all our films (with a particular fondness of horror films, but of course). Yet, as a movie-based website forum (majorly), not having a top 100 non-horror film list is criminal.
For the annals of cinema history is dotted with some superb examples of film making in every other genre - action, fantasy, drama, war, western, adventure, sci-fi, mystery noir, etc. Even musicals have left their mark in cinema history (who can forget that wonderful Singing In The Rain or Mary Poppins?) Don't you think it's high time that we sat down with our collective tastes and chiseled out 100 of the absolute best in cinema as a whole?


So HDC, which shall it be?

Or shall we pursue both?

[Despare]

I'm down for either but I prefer music, I think it would be harder for me to try and peg down even my favorite 100 non-horrors let alone rank them. I'd try like hell though...

[_____V_____]

Originally Posted by Despare

I'm down for either but I prefer music, I think it would be harder for me to try and peg down even my favorite 100 non-horrors let alone rank them. I'd try like hell though...

For that there's a simple solution - break up the non-horror expanse into 10 defining genres, and pick off Top 10 for each of them - and voila, we have our 100.

I am thinking:

Action/Crime/Thriller
Adventure/Fantasy
Drama/Family/Sport
Film-Noir/Mystery
Comedy
Musical
Romance
Sci-Fi
Western
War/History/Biography

Animated films are dotted in every other genre so shouldn't be hard to spot the best ones out of the lot. For example, Wall-E would definitely be in my Sci-Fi Top 10.

Midnight here and bedtime for me. Be back in about 8-9 hours.

[hammerfan]

I like the non-horror top 100.

[totem]

You could easily spread the genres out into 20 categories and include hybrids like Romantic Comedies as well as subgroups like Noir & Psychological Thrillers into their own grouping. Then just do a top 5 for each.

For example, I think it would be odd to see When Harry Met Sally in the same top 10 as The Notebook. Though both are Romance, neither is a similar experience.

It's just a thought.

[Straker]

Both sound like they would be a blast.

[Angra]

Horror Boobies Top 100.

That's a winner.

[Sculpt]

Originally Posted by _____V_____

We have pretty much covered all known bases of the horror genre, except for a few. Going through the Compilations when I was doing the image-link updation (for almost all of them), I was struck with 2 separate compilation ideas.

Top 100 Horror Movie Soundtracks

and

Top 100 Non-Horror Films

For the Movie Soundtracks, I doubt if we will have 100 OST albums defining quality, depth and popularity equally in the genre. So it would be better to go with a top 100 list of individual/single soundtracks than entire OST albums. What say?

For the Non-Horrors, all of us have proved time and again that we love all our films (with a particular fondness of horror films, but of course). Yet, as a movie-based website forum (majorly), not having a top 100 non-horror film list is criminal.
For the annals of cinema history is dotted with some superb examples of film making in every other genre - action, fantasy, drama, war, western, adventure, sci-fi, mystery noir, etc. Even musicals have left their mark in cinema history (who can forget that wonderful Singing In The Rain or Mary Poppins?) Don't you think it's high time that we sat down with our collective tastes and chiseled out 100 of the absolute best in cinema as a whole?

So HDC, which shall it be?

Or shall we pursue both?

Love the idea, V! As is sometimes the case ... I want to make sure I (and everyone else) understand what you're talking about. You wrote, "For the Movie Soundtracks, I doubt if we will have 100 OST albums defining quality, depth and popularity equally in the genre. So it would be better to go with a top 100 list of individual/single soundtracks than entire OST albums."

Defining/Requirements for "single track":
(For others reading this, "OST" is Original Sound Track.) When you say, "better to go with a top 100 list of individual/single soundtracks than entire OST albums", you mean single tracks that appear on a Movie Soundtrack Album, right? And so, three examples of this would be:

• 1. Movie Theme Song: "Original Halloween Theme" from Halloween
• 2. Song "Sung" in Film: "Sacred Springs" from Mothra vs. Godzilla
• 3. Film Score/Background Music/Incidental Music: "The Murder" from Psycho
• 4. (wouldn't recommend) Commercial Song on Soundtrack, a Song Clip Heard in Film: "Partytime" from Return of the Living Dead

Which types should we include?

I would suggest only the first three types be included because, a commercial song from a soundtrack (often a track from a regular commercial music album, as in the case of "Partytime"), is a rather separate entity from the film, sometimes only plays a couple seconds in the film, and sometimes is not heard in the film at all. I think any piece of music from a film really needs to be specifically bound to it.


Compilations?: Horror Film or Non-Horror Film or All Film:
I think the amount of single tracks for a Horror Film music compilation is likely more massive than you might imagine (the 3 examples above). I would recommend restricting to just Horror films. After that's completed, a Non-Horror could be attempted, and would be vast amount of material (imagine multiple single tracks for every film).

[newb]

Originally Posted by hammerfan

I like the non-horror top 100.

yeah.....me like too

[newb]

Originally Posted by Angra

Horror Boobies Top 100.

That's a winner.

yeah...me like to