View Single Post
  #8338  
Old 09-29-2017, 06:49 PM
cheebacheeba's Avatar
cheebacheeba cheebacheeba is offline
That fucking Guy...

 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 7,088
Star Trek: Discovery Ep 1 & 2.

Well, they're definitely on top of production quality, I'll say that first and foremost.

It hasn't really been revealed if this show takes place in the original or "new" reality, or if it's just essentially fitting in with (or ignoring?) both.
Style-wise it looks much more like the JJA universe - but that's just skin deep stuff.

What I found interesting was...
We have a main character. I've seen TNG, a fair bit of TOS, all of Voyager and DS9 and there's never really been so much of a focus on just one person, it's always been more ensemble. Maybe it'll lean into that with the changes episode 2 brought about?
It's not a bad thing. Just different.
She's a little bit of a mixture between what ST usually tries to do with their "fish out of water" characters like Spock, Data, Odo etc, and some of their less "by the book" characters, a trait most strongly recognisable as Kirk-ish.

Another thing there hasn't been too much of, is the early Klingon psychology...in this show, while you see that they are proud, strong, almost religious in their conviction to battle and victory (these parts we know)...you also see that for reasons unknown thus far, they're very fractured, and they really do see the "federation" as a threat to their very way of life and culture.

There's been glimpses of the Klingon way of life before, largely via Worf...but nothing from within the original series or anyplace near that timeline.

The first speech from the Klingon antagonist says it all...he was in no way trying to mince words, gain support among his people through misinformation or anything along those lines - He absolutely believed his very people, their lives and reality were under serious threat.

This is the first time there was almost as much focus on the "other side" as there was the Federation. I actually hope they keep this up as they encounter other species. More writing involved I suppose, but yeah, adds a dimension we've only really seen a very small measure of before.

So.
Without being too nitpicky, I found it enjoyable.
I don't feel as though you need to be a Trekkie, or have even seen anything ST before to jump on at this point, after all, it stands on its own and is set chronologically prior to most of what we've seen before.
Good music.
Nice effects.
Cool ships.
GREAT to hear the sound effects of the computer/s etc from the original series incorporated, and of course the oldskool inspired phaser and ?tricorder? designs were a treat too.

I'll follow this with interest.

If you're more after the TNG era type ST, I'd recommend maybe checking out "The Orville", a good show in it's own right, thankfully not as laugh a minute as Seth Mcfarlanes other stuff...it's quite a respectful send up actually.
__________________
The door opened...you got in..:rolleyes:
Reply With Quote