Rate the Actor Game

[Posher778]

Basically, someone says an actor or actress, and the next person gives them a grade from 1-10 on their acting performance. No giving them zeros if you haven't seen any of their movies, or being weirdly irrational about it, etc. Begin.

Bill Murray

[The_Return]

6...used to be great, but has gone severly downhill.

Cary Grant

[Posher778]

7/10, Not bad really, unless I mixed up the name, which I don't think I did...


Neve Campbell:D

[The_Return]

4...good looking, but face it: She can't act.


Ezra Godden

[pinkfloyd45769]

5
Jimmy Fallon(sp?)

[Posher778]

Originally posted by The_Return
4...good looking, but face it: She can't act.


Ezra Godden

Are you kidding? Your score is your opinion, that's fine, but, ...she's a great actress, and not just IMO either. Can you explain what you thought was wrong?

And fallon... 4




Will Smith

[The_Return]

6.5/10...his movies are usually alot of fun.


As for Neve Campbell...comeon man, you really think she's a good actress? I dont think she changed her expression once in Scream until the very end...no better than the typical fodder in any other slasher movie.


Dennis Hopper

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
Are you kidding? Your score is your opinion, that's fine, but, ...she's a great actress, and not just IMO either. Can you explain what you thought was wrong?

And fallon... 4




Will Smith Will Smith-Fresh Prince-6
Will Smith overall 3
Reese Witherspoon

[The_Return]

Witherspoon - 5/10, she's done a few decent movies.

I repost:

Dennis Hopper

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by The_Return
Witherspoon - 5/10, she's done a few decent movies.

I repost:

Dennis Hopper 6
Tom Cruise

[The_Return]

5...he has his moments, but his public persona gets in the way.


Micheal J. Fox

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by The_Return
5...he has his moments, but his public persona gets in the way.


Micheal J. Fox 7
Tom Hanks

[The_Return]

4, Im not a big fan. He was great in Cast Away though.

Peter Sellers

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by The_Return
4, Im not a big fan. He was great in Cast Away though.

Peter Sellers 1,don't know who he is
Dustin Hoffman

[The_Return]

WHAT!?!?

How could you not know Peter Sellers?? One of the greatest actors of all time! The Pink Panther series, The Party, Being There, Dr. Strangelove....! If you havent seen any of those...go! Go now and rent!


Anyway...

7/10...consistantly gives a good performance, but rarely gives a great one.


John Travolta

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by The_Return
WHAT!?!?

How could you not know Peter Sellers?? One of the greatest actors of all time! The Pink Panther series, The Party, Being There, Dr. Strangelove....! If you havent seen any of those...go! Go now and rent!


Anyway...

7/10...consistantly gives a good performance, but rarely gives a great one.


John Travolta 10, i love Travolta!
Julia Roberts
I know who Sellers is now, i guess i went blank!

[The_Return]

Julia Roberts...blech. 4/10...a couple decent performances.


Ian McKellan

[The_Return]

By the way, Im out for the night. See ya!

[Posher778]

7/10

And I think that was Neve's whole POINT in the scream movies, but, if you think she's monotone or something, watch scream 2, she's semi happier.

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by The_Return
By the way, Im out for the night. See ya! Nighty Night!! :p

[Posher778]

Oh, btw.


Katie Holmes

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
Oh, btw.


Katie Holmes 4
JLO :p

[_____V_____]

3

Bruce Campbell

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by _____V_____
3

Bruce Campbell 2
Jack Black

[Posher778]

1, he's so overrated imo.


Christian Bale

[_____V_____]

4

Vincent Price

[Posher778]

7

Matt Damon

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
7

Matt Damon 5.5
Jackie Chan

[Posher778]

3, stick with the board smashin OFF SCREEN...



Chris Rock

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
3, stick with the board smashin OFF SCREEN...



Chris Rock 6
Jennifer Aniston

[The_Return]

3

Grace Kelly

[Posher778]

4



Courteney Cox

[AUSTIN316426808]

4

Christopher Walken

[The_Return]

A solid 8.

Ray Wise

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.7/10


Willem Dafoe

[scouse mac]

6


Bill Paxton

[Thomasgeorge]

4




ryan renalds

[AUSTIN316426808]

3/10


Bill Moseley

[scouse mac]

5 (he's a little over-rated)


Paul Bettany

[AUSTIN316426808]

7/10


Paul Giamatti

[scouse mac]

8.5


Val Kilmer

[AUSTIN316426808]

8/10


James Woods

[Posher778]

Not very familiar, so... I don't think i can judge yet, sorry.


John Jaratt

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
Not very familiar, so... I don't think i can judge yet, sorry.


John Jaratt 2
John Wayne

[Posher778]

6

Carrie Ann Moss

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
6

Carrie Ann Moss 4
Ben Stiller

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.5/10


Vince Vaughn

[scouse mac]

4


Richard Burton

[AUSTIN316426808]

7/10


Michael Keaton

[_____V_____]

6 (he was the perfect Batman and Beetlejuice)

Kiera Knightley

[scouse mac]

6


Bill Murray

[AUSTIN316426808]

6


Al Pacino

[scouse mac]

7

(and fading fast, every role he has played in recent years he doesn't play the character, he plays Al Pacino shouting alot)


Lee Van Cleef

[AUSTIN316426808]

7.5


Bruce Willis


Whenever I post in here I go by entire body of work and/or the best I've seen the actor. Having said that I'd would've given Pacino at least an 8.5.

[scouse mac]

6


Samuel L Jackson



I base this on every film ive seen them in and try to give an overall score eg. Big Al's performance in Heat is negated by his performance in Every Given Sunday.

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.5


Russell Crowe

[scouse mac]

7


Jaoquin Pheonix

[AUSTIN316426808]

8/10


Matt Dillon

[scouse mac]

5.5


Ben Affleck

[AUSTIN316426808]

5


Matt Damon

[scouse mac]

5


Johnny Depp

[AUSTIN316426808]

10/10


Viggo Mortensen

[scouse mac]

7.5


Mira Sorvino

[Posher778]

7, i loved her performance in Mimic.

Milla Jovovich

[AUSTIN316426808]

4/10


Sean Connery

[Posher778]

7/10




Johnny Depp

[The_Return]

He was already used, like 4 people ago...I agree with Austin's vote.

10/10, one of the greatest actors alive today that is yet to win an Oscar.


Ralph Finnes

[Posher778]

Sorry, i'm really zoned, just fell asleep three hours ago out of nowhere and i'm confused tonight, but anyway.

5/10

Roy Scheider

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.5/10


Richard Dreyfuss


A 5/10 for Ralph Finnes? To each his own.

[Posher778]

6 for dreyfuss


david arquette

[The_Return]

6

Sean Penn

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
6 for dreyfuss


david arquette 7, i liked him in the Scream movies
Paris Hilton(i'm probably the only one who likes her) :o

[Posher778]

4, I liked her in H.O.W, she didn't do all that bad.


Elisha Cuthbert

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
4, I liked her in H.O.W, she didn't do all that bad.


Elisha Cuthbert 4
Kirsten Dunst

[Posher778]

7

Morgan Freeman

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
7

Morgan Freeman 6
Ashley Judd

[Posher778]

8 , I loved her in double jeopardy

Ben Affleck

[AUSTIN316426808]

5


Clive Owen

[AUSTIN316426808]

So going by these last couple pages Kirsten Dunst and David Arquette are better actors than Morgan Freeman and Richard Dreyfuss. Whatever yall are smokin, I want some.

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by AUSTIN316426808
So going by these last couple pages Kirsten Dunst and David Arquette are better actors than Morgan Freeman and Richard Dreyfuss. Whatever yall are smokin, I want some. I don't give much thought before i answer. I love Richard Dreyfuss, i would have given him a 10.

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by AUSTIN316426808
5


Clive Owen 8
Gene Hackman

[AUSTIN316426808]

Originally posted by pinkfloyd45769
I don't give much thought before i answer. I love Richard Dreyfuss, i would have given him a 10.


It's all just opinion, I was just stating my side of the story.

[AUSTIN316426808]

Originally posted by pinkfloyd45769
8
Gene Hackman


10


John Cusack

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by AUSTIN316426808
10


John Cusack 6
Nicolas Cage

[AUSTIN316426808]

8.5


Daniel Day-Lewis

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by AUSTIN316426808
8.5


Daniel Day-Lewis 7
Hillary Swank

[AUSTIN316426808]

8.5


Jodie Foster

[Dante'sInferno]

10



Edward Norton.

[AUSTIN316426808]

7


Mel Gibson

[Dante'sInferno]

3(I think he's overrated.)




Christopher Walken

[AUSTIN316426808]

9


James Caviezel

[Dante'sInferno]

7.85




Brandon Lee

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.8


Robert Redford

[scouse mac]

7.5


Michael Caine

[AUSTIN316426808]

9


Alan Rickman

[_____V_____]

6

Mark Hamill

[AUSTIN316426808]

8 (Would've been a 6 but he gets the extra 2 for his voice work.)



Donald Sutherland

[scouse mac]

6


Sam Neill

[_____V_____]

6

Tom Berenger

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by _____V_____
6

Tom Berenger 6
Nicole Kidman

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.9



Billy Crudup

[Posher778]

5.4

Dennis Quaid

[hammerfan]

Originally posted by Posher778
5.4

Dennis Quaid

8

Hugh Jackman

[AUSTIN316426808]

7


Jeremy Irons

[_____V_____]

8

Gregory Peck?

[hammerfan]

Originally posted by _____V_____
8

Gregory Peck?

9

Henry Fonda

[_____V_____]

8

Laurence Fishburne?

[hammerfan]

Originally posted by _____V_____
8

Laurence Fishburne?

7


Jesse L. Martin

[_____V_____]

4

Winona Ryder?

[hammerfan]

Originally posted by _____V_____
4

Winona Ryder?

1

Gwyneth Paltrow

[_____V_____]

6 (3 for performance, and 3 for her looks)

Johnny Depp

[hammerfan]

Originally posted by _____V_____
6 (3 for performance, and 3 for her looks)

Johnny Depp

10

Crispin Glover

[_____V_____]

5

Julia Stiles

[hammerfan]

Originally posted by _____V_____
5

Julia Stiles

5

Helena Bonham Carter

[_____V_____]

4

Julia Roberts

[Posher778]

7


Robert Englund

[The_Return]

6...he's great as Freddy, but he's definatly a one trick pony. The only non-NOES movie Ive seen that he was good in is Wishmaster.


Kane Hodder

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by The_Return
6...he's great as Freddy, but he's definatly a one trick pony. The only non-NOES movie Ive seen that he was good in is Wishmaster.


Kane Hodder 5.5
Hillary Duff :p

[The_Return]

-58

Christian Bale

[AUSTIN316426808]

10/10



Naomi Watts

[_____V_____]

5

Bill Pullman

[Posher778]

6


Bridget Fonda

[AUSTIN316426808]

5


Bill Paxton

[scouse mac]

8.5


Guy Pierce

[AUSTIN316426808]

8


Richard Gere

[scouse mac]

7


John Cusack

[_____V_____]

4

Kate Beckinsale

[scouse mac]

3 (she looks good but sod all else)


James Caan

[AUSTIN316426808]

8.5


Talia Shire

[scouse mac]

7


Henry Fonda

[AUSTIN316426808]

9


Jane Fonda

[scouse mac]

5


Kirk Douglas

[AUSTIN316426808]

8


Laurence Olivier

[scouse mac]

9


John Hurt

[AUSTIN316426808]

7.5


Hugo Weaving

[scouse mac]

7


Tom Berenger

[AUSTIN316426808]

7


Owen Wilson

[scouse mac]

5


Heath Ledger

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.5
For Brokeback Mountain and the potential he has for the duration of his career...10



Jake Gyllenhaal

[scouse mac]

7.5


Maggie Gyllenhaal

[AUSTIN316426808]

7


Chris Cooper

[Posher778]

6

Sigourney Weaver

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.9


Cillian Murphy

[scouse mac]

6.5


Christian Bale

[AUSTIN316426808]

10/10


Tim Robbins

[scouse mac]

8


Susan Sarandon

[AUSTIN316426808]

7


Benicio Del Toro

[Posher778]

Not very familiar.

Portia De Rossi

[AUSTIN316426808]

5.5



Lucy Lui

[Posher778]

8, Loved her in Charlies Angels, as well as a lot others.


Keanu Reaves

[AUSTIN316426808]

5.9


Ving Rhames

[_____V_____]

6

Elijah Wood

[Posher778]

5



Patrick Warburton

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Posher778
5



Patrick Warburton 5

Robin Williams

[Posher778]

6

Uma Thurman

[AUSTIN316426808]

7


Eric Bana

[_____V_____]

5

Matthew Modine

[AUSTIN316426808]

5


Michael Madsen

[_____V_____]

4 (he got a plain face IMO)

Marlon Brando

[AUSTIN316426808]

11/10



Harrison Ford

[scouse mac]

7.5



Sean Connery

[Posher778]

7, great actor, but he's so irritable to everybody.

Neve Campbell (again)

[AUSTIN316426808]

5.5



Rachel Weisz

[_____V_____]

4

Tom Berenger

[scouse mac]

6



Billy Bob Thornton

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by scouse mac
6



Billy Bob Thornton Some of his movies were great,8
Jason Biggs

[Yellow Jacket]

5

Cillian Murphy

Movies: Red Eye, Batman Begins, Breakfast on Pluto

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by Yellow Jacket
5

Cillian Murphy

Movies: Red Eye, Batman Begins, Breakfast on Pluto 9, he's hot!!!
Jason Mewes

[_____V_____]

5

Ian McKellen

[scouse mac]

8.5


Danny Glover

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.9



John Malkovich

[_____V_____]

6

Dustin Hoffman

[scouse mac]

8


Angelina Jolie

[AUSTIN316426808]

7


James Stewart

[scouse mac]

8.75


Ernest Borgnine

[_____V_____]

6

Frank Sinatra

[scouse mac]

Originally posted by _____V_____
Frank Sinatra

2


Gene Hackman

[Posher778]

8


Halle Berry(sp?)

[AUSTIN316426808]

You spelled it right.

7


Patrick Stewart

[Posher778]

7

Patrick Swayze

[_____V_____]

5

Arnold Schwarzenegger

[Posher778]

3


Lucille Ball

[scouse mac]

4


Marilyn Monroe

[Posher778]

9
JLo

[scouse mac]

4


Meg Ryan

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.9


Ken Wantanabe

[Posher778]

4

Hilary duff!:o

[AUSTIN316426808]

1/10



Mark Wahlberg

[Posher778]

4

John Jarratt

[scouse mac]

7


Bill Murray

[Posher778]

7.5, I like a bunch of his movies.


Rose Mcgowan

[scouse mac]

5


Jude Law

[AUSTIN316426808]

7.4


Tommy Lee Jones

[Posher778]

8


Ashley Judd

[_____V_____]

7

Laurence Fishburne (sp?)

[AUSTIN316426808]

You spelled it right...


7



Charlie Sheen

[scouse mac]

6



Sean Pertwee

[AUSTIN316426808]

6


Pierce Brosnan

[scouse mac]

6.75


Roger Moore

[_____V_____]

7 (thanks Austin)

Charles Bronson?

[AUSTIN316426808]

5.9

Chuck Norris

[scouse mac]

10

(i would normally rate him at a modest 3 or 4, but im certain he would find me and kill me)


Bruce Lee

[AUSTIN316426808]

6



Brad Pitt

[scouse mac]

6


Edward Norton

[AUSTIN316426808]

7.5



Michael Douglas

[scouse mac]

7


John Travolta

[AUSTIN316426808]

7.9


Anthony Hopkins

[scouse mac]

8.5



Jodie Foster

[AUSTIN316426808]

9



Christopher Plummer

[pinkfloyd45769]

Originally posted by AUSTIN316426808
9



Christopher Plummer 7
Jamie Lee Curtis

[_____V_____]

6

Thomas Jane

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.5

Will Patton

[Posher778]

5

Jennifer Love Hewitt (hisss)

[AUSTIN316426808]

4.5


James Franco

[Dante'sInferno]

5



Asia Argento.

[AUSTIN316426808]

5



Dennis Hopper

[Dante'sInferno]

I like him.8/10





Nick Stahl

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.9


Benicio Del Toro

[Dante'sInferno]

7.5





Mickey Rourke(sp?)

[GorePhobia]

Great actor especially in Sin City

8.5

Mickey Rourke PWNS!!

Clive Owen

[AUSTIN316426808]

8



Michael Clarke Duncan

[GorePhobia]

I smell a wave of Sin City going on.

7

Bruce Willis

[AUSTIN316426808]

7


Jessica Alba

[GorePhobia]

6 (only because she is hot her acting is piss poor)

Rosario Dawson

[AUSTIN316426808]

5.5



Kevin Costner

[Dante'sInferno]

6





Josh Hartnett(Hah,i get the one that sucks.)

[GorePhobia]

7


Jonathan Rhys Meyers

[AUSTIN316426808]

6.6



Cate Blanchett

[GorePhobia]

hmmmm only a 6.6 for Jonathan....i thought he was great in Match Point

6

Scarlett Johansson

[AUSTIN316426808]

Haven't really seen Match Point, the one time I was supposed to be watching it I got side tracked.



8.5


Liam Neeson

[GorePhobia]

8.5

Liam is a great actor.
(You should definately finish watching it when you get time.)


Chrisitan Bale

[AUSTIN316426808]

10



Leonardo DiCaprio

[GorePhobia]

6 (Never really liked his work, only liked him in Gangs of New York and What's Eating Gilbert Grape?)



Edward Norton

[AUSTIN316426808]

7



Steve Buscemi


@Gore- could you take a look in the last seen movie thread, gotta question for ya.

[GorePhobia]

8.5


Kevin Spacey


@Austin - Alrighty

[AUSTIN316426808]

10

Not doing that great since American Beauty but you can't let that blind you off the great performances.


Warren Beatty

[GorePhobia]

8

I havent seen Beatty do anything in awhile.



The Rock

[AUSTIN316426808]

As an action star I'd give him a 10, for his acutally acting ability...about a 6.



Uma Thurman

[GorePhobia]

I think he does a pretty good job acting, better then some people I watch on the big screen.

I give Uma a 9 only because Kill Bill was so amazing and she was great in Les Meserables.

(this is my last one for the day)


David Carradine

[AUSTIN316426808]

7



Lucy Liu

[Dante'sInferno]

8




Tea Leoni'(or something)

[_____V_____]

4 (you spelled correct)

Sidney Poitier

[GorePhobia]

7


Matt Damon

[Dante'sInferno]

8




Edward Norton

[_____V_____]

4

Jennifer Connelly

[Dante'sInferno]

4




Thora Birtch

[scouse mac]

8


Jason Biggs

[Dante'sInferno]

6




Mena Suvari

[GorePhobia]

5



Bruce Campbell

[Dante'sInferno]

7



Quentin Tarnintino(From what you have seen of him)